Freedom4um

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Miscellaneous
See other Miscellaneous Articles

Title: Hague court orders Russia to pay $50 billion in Yukos oil case
Source: [None]
URL Source: [None]
Published: Jul 29, 2014
Author: Isabel Gorst
Post Date: 2014-07-29 01:01:08 by Tatarewicz
Keywords: None
Views: 51
Comments: 3

LA Times... The Kremlin expropriated Yukos in 2005; GML group was seeking $114 billion Mikhail Khodorkovsky, Yukos' founder, was sentenced in 2005 to 10 years; Vladimir Putin pardoned him last year 'This is a great day for the rule of law,' said Emmanuel Gaillard, New York-based attorney

A court in the Netherlands has ordered Russia to pay more than $50 billion in damages to the former shareholders of the now defunct Yukos oil corporation that was dismembered in a controversial bankruptcy case nearly a decade ago.

In the ruling Monday, the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague said it would award GML group just under half of its $114-billion claim to help compensate for losses incurred when the Kremlin expropriated Yukos in 2005. lRelated Russian foreign minister holds to hard line on Ukraine

Europe Russian foreign minister holds to hard line on Ukraine

See all related 8

“This award is a major victory for us,” said Tim Osborne, director of GML. “After intense scrutiny, the tribunal confirmed what the claimants have been saying all along, namely that Yukos was destroyed, and its assets expropriated for political reasons.”

Sergei Lavrov, the Russian foreign minister, said Russia would appeal the ruling. Agencies representing Russia in the case would “use all available legal options to defend its position,” he said. cComments

The ruling does not come as a surprise, but the timing couldn't have been more coincidental with the downing of flight MH17. The Permanent Court for Arbitration is in The Hague, so the ruling provides a sense of satisfaction for the Dutch population, as most of the victims on board of... j. von hettlingen at 3:15 PM July 28, 2014

Add a comment See all comments 7

Once Russia’s biggest oil company, Yukos was crippled by alleged federal tax debts and sold off at bankruptcy auctions in 2006 and 2007. Rosneft, Russia’s state oil company, bagged most of Yukos’ best assets at the sales, which came as the Kremlin stepped up a campaign to reassert government control over the lucrative oil industry.

Mikhail Khodorkovsky, Yukos' founder, was sentenced in 2005 to 10 years in prison on charges of tax evasion and fraud that many observers believed were politically motivated to punish the billionaire tycoon for challenging the Kremlin’s increasingly authoritarian policies.

Russian President Vladimir Putin pardoned Khodorkovsky late last year.

Yukos’ former shareholders, who promised Russia a “lifetime of legislation” when the company was seized, have been fighting for compensation for nearly a decade.

“This is a great day for the rule of law,” said Emmanuel Gaillard, the head of international arbitration at Shearman & Sterling, the New York-based legal firm. “A superpower like the Russian Federation is held accountable for its violations of international law by an independent tribunal of the highest possible caliber.”

In a statement Monday, Rosneft said it had not participated in the arbitration process and was not bound by the court's rulings. "Rosneft believes that all of its purchases of former Yukos assets, and all other actions taken by it with respect to Yukos were entirely lawful and proper," the statement said.

The court ruling comes at a difficult time for Russia, which is battling an economic contraction that has been exacerbated by fallout from the Ukraine crisis.

In the coming days, the European Union is expected to vote on a package of tough economic sanctions targeting the Russian oil, banking and defense sectors, in a bid to force the Kremlin to change its policies in Ukraine.

Under terms of the arbitration court ruling, Russia will be obliged to pay the compensation to Yukos shareholders by Jan. 15, 2015, or face additional demands for interest on the sum.

Special correspondent Gorst reported from Moscow. Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Tatarewicz (#0)

Russian President Vladimir Putin pardoned Khodorkovsky late last year

Interesting.

But I doubt Putin has any respect for a Hague ( Zio) judicial ruling.

Possession is 9/10 of the law.

scrapper2  posted on  2014-07-29   1:38:29 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: Tatarewicz (#0)

the former shareholders of the now defunct Yukos oil corporation

Didn't it come out that Khodorkovsky was just another front man for the rothschild family?

Those international lice serve no purpose to humanity. I vote for extermination rather than tribute.

It's the bankers fault !

Buzzard  posted on  2014-07-29   6:42:37 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: Buzzard (#2)

The Dork borrowed money from Rothbank to buy up Russian oil the income from which would likely go in part to Israel; same as with Israeli lobby using agents to elect US Congress which then funds Israel. The following RussiaToday story and subsequent comments gives a fuller picture:

The International Arbitration Court in the Netherlands has ended a decade long case brought by shareholders in the defunct Yukos oil company, and ordered Russia to pay about $50 billion in damages.

READ MORE: Hague court had no authority in Yukos case, ruling politicized – Moscow

The official ruling published on Monday said Russia violated the EU Energy Charter when it redistributed the company’s assets and “took steps equivalent to expropriation of the claimants’ investment in Yukos.”

The Hague’s Permanent Court of Arbitration ordered Russia to compensate the plaintiffs with $50 billion – less than half the initial $114 billion demanded by the former shareholders. Russia has also been ordered to pay about $65 million in legal costs.

“This is the biggest arbitration award in history,” as ITAR-TASS quotes Emmanuel Gilyard, a lawyer at the Shearman Sterling bureau, who underlined that the case became a ‘mega-arbitration’.

As part of the case, three separate lawsuits by former Yukos shareholders were filed by Hulley Enterprises Limited (Cyprus), Yukos Universal Limited (Isle of Man) and Veteran Petroleum Limited (Cyprus).

The court ruled that $39.97 billion of the compensation should go to Hulley Enterprises, $1.85 billion to Yukos Universal and $8.2 billion for Veteran Petroleum Limited. The Veteran Petroleum fund acts in the interest of former Yukos employees and should receive another $8.2 billion.

The claim was lodged by Gibraltar-based Group Menatep Limited (GML) - the company used by Russia’s once richest man Mikhail Khodorkovsky to manage Yukos.

Russia has until January 2015 to pay the compensation; otherwise it will start being charged interest. The country's Finance Ministry said it would appeal the decision in the Netherlands.

"I am delighted to confirm that those final awards, which were unanimous, are very favorable to the claimants," Tim Osborne, director of the GML group of shareholders which brought the action, told Reuters.

Former Yukos shareholders said on Monday they had not ruled out the possibility of a lawsuit against Rosneft and its shareholders, including BP, for their role in the redistribution of Yukos’ assets. Osborne had previously said that if the Russian state refuses to pay the compensation, then the shareholders could file a lawsuit against BP as a Rosneft shareholder.

“There is no reason to think Russia will not fulfill its international obligations. But if this were to happen, the New York Convention, which obligates 150 signature states to work together to ensure the arbitration ruling is upheld – would come in effect,” said Osborne

Rosneft released a statement on Monday following the ruling, saying that it does not consider itself liable in the Yukos case as it acted in accordance with Russian law in its acquisition of the company’s assets.

“Rosneft does not bear any responsibility in the published ruling,” said the statement. “Rosneft believes that its acquisition of Yukos’ assets was conducted in accordance with the applicable laws.” The Yukos saga

The downfall of Yukos began with the arrest of its CEO Mikhail Khodorkovsky on fraud charges in 2003. The company's assets were frozen while the investigation was carried out.

Several months later, Moscow said Yukos owed the government $27 billion in tax. The oil giant's shares plummeted and it was sold off to other Russian companies. The decimated Yukos finally filed for bankruptcy in July 2006.

Soon after the bankruptcy the company’s shareholders applied to The Hague International Arbitration Court claiming $100 billion in compensation.

With the bankruptcy of Yukos its assets were absorbed by the state oil company Rosneft.

A year ago, the European Court of Human Rights ruled the case against Mikhail Khodorkovsky and Yukos was not politically-motivated.

Mikhail Khodorkovsky spent more than a decade behind bars before President Putin granted him an early release.

READ MORE: Ex-oil tycoon Khodorkovsky leaves prison after pardon

However, Eric Kraus, a political risk analyst, told RT The Hague Court's ruling appears biased.

“It strikes me as a very political decision. The West manages to create this illusion of a fair play rule of law, of fairness of judicial process and this is a bad joke,” he said.

Mr. Kraus said Khodorkovsky was found guilty by both Russia and the European Court of Human Rights.

“It is outrageous that anyone should imagine that Russia is going to pay $50 billion to these criminals,” Kraus said.

(from 443 comments):

mike So how about the Russian government suing Yukos shareholders for stealing state owned assets using influence and crooked deals etc? Yukos shareolders deserve nothing since they bought the company for basically nothing! When the state took the company back they should end up in jail instead of being able to sue.

Enrique...A politically motivated decission which makes the Arbitration Court less credible.

K hodorkovsky, which at 30 didn´t have a kopec in his pocket, got assets from the Russian Government worth over $ 50 bn. to manage them as a CEO in a market economy.

That was his task for the Government of Boris Yeltsin....Those assets belong to the Russian People, and obviously a soviet guy without a kopec didn´t have the money to buy them. And, if we add that Yukos didn´t pay much in taxes..

It is the Russian Government the one which should receive over $ 20 bn. in compensation for unpaid taxes.

Rasly Walker

It's almost funny. Oligarch who stole funds from this company and became billionairs now sue Russia, the very people they stole the money from

.

africaboy Jasiri This 'judgement' is a political one brought forward to pressure Russia/Putin. It is just one of many that the 'West' is using to bring Russia to heel. Another one is the old Litvinenko Case just recently ressurected in London. Russia, China, Iran, Venezuala, Argentina, Bolivia, Syria and all those allied to them are being targeted by the 'West' because they refuse to toe the line. The recent summit in Fortaleza where the BRICS outlined plans for their New Development Bank was for the 'West', the final straw!

Russia has the minded people to face the challenge

progressive-world ...From TASS, about one of the crooks, called shareholders:

Nevzlin, who was sentenced in absentia to life imprisonment by a Russian court for plotting murders and kidnappings and is currently living in Israel.

--- -------------------- ---

Would Russia pay a terrible criminal?

That is what the war criminal americans want and their agents like freeworldlogic want.

tekno mytekno "'Tommy Udo' ~ "Since there is absolutely no way Russia will end up paying, this should show international investor's that you invest in Russia at your own risk."

Agreed, this should show international banksters that you cant collapse political system and then come in and loot the country, through privatization. This should be an example to IMF, World Bank and Int; Banksters who like to "privatize" ; national assets around the globe. Ukraine is next to be "re-privatized& quot;.

Zai Dear Russians and the brave President Putin. Don't pay a single dollar because all these courts are American and her allies court, it not justice, its another MH17 accusing Russia and Russians know that these kind of things will keep going against Russia, why the international court of justice is not bringing Bush and Toney to justice who killed millions of innocent women and children, more than the World War 1 and 11. Live long president Putin.

Karl Marx...Yukos cheated on its taxes to Russia, its assets were seized, and then sold to satisfy its tax debts. Now the Hague expects Russia to pay off corporate investors?

If this scenario had taken place in the US, NO ONE would dare sue the United States government to recover assets lost to tax evasion.

Such hypocrisy!!

[quote name='Mark Snova' time Dea r Zai, as this is the same Court Russia is using to claim the money owned by Ukraine for gas - are you felling STUPID, now ? :))))

[/quo te]

Arbitra ge court in Stockholm in that case. Besides, it's not about which court, but what agreements and treaties are ratified by the parties in the proceedings

Lamotte Cason Mike Post...Good luck collecting! This will teach all how to do business with Russia again.

Do you think the U.S. does business honestly and fairly when foreign businesses invest in American properties and deposit its funds in American banks when the United States can holler SANCTION and repossess all funds and purchased properties when the vested foreign businesses or their country say or do something to offend Uncle Sam? Don't think other foreign governments like China who happens to be one of the U.S. biggest investors aren't watching? Be amusing if this cause them to pull back their investments.

edward r Let them take it from the gold that Russia deposited in Fort Knox when the Dollar became the World's reserve Currency.

Derek Maher ...Poor Russia, They are still a bit innocent when it comes to the capitalist system. Most likely a lot of those Yukos shares have been already bought up by vulture speculators for cents on the dollar from the original investors. Argentina has also been caught in this type of legal sting for billions Now sanctions will not be needed as assets can be seized on mass or the debtor country is declared in default.

verner ... there's another tweak in the general situation and that is that a foreign corporation can't ever expect to win a courtcase in america against an american corporation. and that is precisely why a corporation intending to contract with an american company must make sure disputes shall not be settled in america and that the arbitrators are named and not american at any cost! the judiciary in america is as corrupt as the washington dc bunch of crooks and mus at all costs be avoided. bribery in america is par for the course and a foreign corp can never pay enough, since washington will always have the last word!

SchwartzWeiss ...

tartanpion trucmuche ...This decision is obviously political but it is a judicial decision that will be binding between all parties.

The International Arbitration Court has NO judicial power. It has a secretariat type role within the International Chamber of Commerce! The worst that can happen is that they cancel Russia's membership in the chamber. As for $50bn... as if any smart country/state system would EVER pay investors compensation for company fraud. There's only ONE Wall St, and the taxpayers foot the bill in case of fraud. The rest of the world is smarter.

verner... [quote name='Derek Maher' time='...7']Poor Russia, They are still a bit innocent when it comes to the capitalist system etc'

doubt a state's assets can be seized by any one - thus a state owned asset is protected from creditors (unless special provisions in the underlying documents specify to the contrary. argent ina is a prime example of america's disregard of any laws and shameful and only proves that washington dc is as crooked as a 3-dollar bill. the same applies to yukos of course and illustrates how the west is prepared to bend any laws and tweak any contract to it's own favour.

Jean de Peyrelongue ...I hope that Putin will ignore that order. Yukos stole the Russian population. Yukos asset belongs to the russian people. Paying those bandits would be a treason toward the russian people. Putin should clearly reject that abject New World Order. It is time for Russia to says " enough is enough " and have the european people understand that should a war occur, Europe will be destroyed.

Eduardo... if this so called " international " court is for real, it has to prosecute the Wall street Pedofile Mafia for destroying Libya, Iraq in order to save the Petro-Dollar.

SchwartzWeiss ... Bob Neeyano...

Exactly. The next billionaire won't be so fast to invest in Russia

Precisely, that's why Khodorkovsky went to jail and why his backers want their dough back. Same with all the foreign billionaires who created the Russian, Ukrainian and other post soviet oligarchs in drunken Yeltsin's days as their frontmen. That's why they're after Putin. He rained on their parade, the one they had under Yeltsin and the one which almost dragged Russia into 3 world poverty and into foreign controlled disaster.

SchwartzWeiss

Mark Snova ... The International Arbitration Court

Go for it if you like but look up who the IAC and the are ICC first just so you know where you are before you drop your pants down. lol

And while ur at it check out who owns the copyright to the International Arbitration Court name (hint: International Chamber of Commerce maybe?) Classic BS to pull the wool over everyone's eyes. It's no "court". It's a registered trade name owned by a business club. Guess who owns the club? You really need to wipe the propaganda fog from ur eyes.

SchwartzWeiss...quote name='krod' time='28.07.2014 15:35']And now average russians will have to pay the bill. quote]

What ? You think Wall St reaches that far? Not enough already skinning the average American it needs to skin the Russian too?

Jean de Peyrelongue ... I have the feeling that Russia's behaviour toward the New World Order managed by Washington and the Zionists is similar to Haiti's behaviour having ousted the French. Instead of understanding that you cannot make a fair deal with the Devil, they are trying to be accepted by Satan. Haiti paid a heavy price for that and have never recovered from that mistake. Only Fidel Castro understood that; and he never make a deal with the Devil. He is the example to be followed.

Jean de Peyrelongue ...

If Russia takes the loss, I hope it will be a wake-up call for Putin. The New World Order Empire managed by Washington and the Zionists wants Putin and Russia to surrender as Europe already did. With the end of the republic, a system bourgeois, liberal, industrial and merchant, we will see a new Roman empire, a system with a very small corrupted, and billionaire elite and a multitude of slaves. Putin could save the world by taking the lead of a crusade against that Empire. If he surrenders, there is no more hope, the world is doomed.

rt.com/business/176064-yukos-russia-50bn-damages/

Tatarewicz  posted on  2014-07-29   7:46:16 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest