See other War, War, War Articles
Title: Afghan Outlook Bleak as Taliban Grabs Territory
Source:
[None]
URL Source: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,564121,00.html
Published: Oct 12, 2009
Author: AP
Post Date: 2009-10-12 08:38:53 by Jethro Tull
Keywords: None
Views: 146
Comments: 8
Monday, October 12, 2009
AP Sept. 25: U.S. Army Staff Sgt. Gerrad Mitchell patrols in Afghanistan with comrades from 4th Battalion, 25th Field Artillery Regiment.
KABUL — Editors' Note: Associated Press reporter Jason Straziuso spent more than three years in Afghanistan as AP's chief correspondent. This is his final report.
My closest Afghan friend held out his Taliban-era photo. A decade younger, he had a thick black beard that the oppressive regime forced men to grow.
My friend won't grow one again. He is already thinking about when to flee.
As generals, politicians and pundits in Washington debate the next best step for America's eight-year war in Afghanistan, the Taliban takes new territory by the day, despite the record 64,000 U.S. troops here.
I arrived in Afghanistan in spring 2006, just as violence began to explode. I leave after three years as the chief correspondent for The Associated Press, and never have things seemed so ominous. As one of America's top military analysts, Anthony Cordesman, says: The U.S. "is now decisively losing."
No one thinks Kabul will fall while American forces are here. But even top U.S. commander Gen. Stanley McChrystal's latest assessment says that without reversing insurgent momentum in the next 12 months, defeating the insurgency will no longer be possible.
The quiet truth whispered by soldiers in the field and aid workers in Kabul is that the Afghan government is noh, rising U.S. deaths 52; that it could be too late.
McChrystal knows the issue of civilian deaths caused by U.S. forces has turned many Afghans against the West. I witnessed my first such deaths in the summer of 2006, when I shadowed Lt. Will Felder and his platoon on a night-time helicopter invasion of Helmand province's Baghran valley.
Felder, a West Point graduate who left the Army in June after fulfilling his five-year commitment, battled in Helmand, Kandahar and Paktika provinces. He is frank about his time here.
"The things that we were able to accomplish tactically obviously were useless. You can pretty much point to every area we gained, to any sort of tactical success, and in the intervening years those areas have been lost and gained tactically many times," Felder told me from Atlanta, where he is a first-year law student.
"The only thing I can take away from it being successful is none of my soldiers got killed," he said.
It waas on Felder's mission in Baghran that I saw a B-1 bomber destroy a mud house that militants had overrun, killing an apparently innocent elderly couple inside.
"We moved into an area, secured it, at the loss of American lives and certainly Afghan lives, spending a great deal of money and making promises to civilians in the area," he said. "And then we left."
The U.S. was also slow to identify the Taliban comeback for what it was. A top U.S. military official in Kabul told me that for too many years the rising violence here was mistakenly seen as a rise in crime, the drug trade, and corruption. Instead, he said, it was the beginning of an insurgency against the government.
The Taliban's leaders, and their Al Qaeda partners in Pakistan, decided to make a stand, "to fight the West," the official said.
Now, the harsh social rules that Taliban imposed under their reign in the 1990s ha's ambassador to Afghanistan, Zamir Kabulov, recently told AP that McChrystal is trying his best to succeed, but that "at this stage it will be very difficult for him to change the direction" of the war.
"The more troops you bring the more troubles you will have here," said Kabulov, who knows from the experience of the Soviets, who were defeated bitterly in Afghanistan more than two decades ago.
My memories of Afghanistan will last forever: The kids chasing kites. Cringing every time a U.S. convoy passed, because of the threat of a bomb attack. Hearing bullets whiz over my head while in the field with troops. Seeing a rare woman driver. And seeing a little Afghan girl burned within an inch of her life by white phosphorus rescued by U.S. military doctors.
A best-case scenario for the country is that the U.S. and NATO train enough Afghan soldiers to protect the provincial capitals, and the U.S. maintains a small counter-terrorism force to watch over Al Qaeda and Pakistan. The wild hinterlands will be left for the Taliban.
But Zaeef believes the Taliban will rule again one day, though they may not be able to take Kabul by force. How long will America stay? As the Taliban likes to say: "The Americans have the watches, but the Taliban has the time."
That is why my Afghan friend has already decided he will sell his home and leave Afghanistan if the Taliban infiltrate Kabul. My friend survived one Taliban regime. He is now laying plans so he won't have to do it again.
Afghan Outlook Bleak as Taliban Grabs Territory
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#1. To: Jethro Tull (#0)
(Edited)
Sounds like Vietnam on a smaller scale, the bleeding and dying continues. With Pakistan next door ready to implode any day, Obumski fiddles while good men die.
In 1963, my first year in HS, my English class was given an assignment with the title, "How would you end the war in Vietnam." As my classmates scribbled away lengthy plans, I handed in my paper after two sentences. My plan was to warn Hanoi that either they should surrender unconditionally within 72 hours, or be prepared to evacuate the city forthwith as all options were on the table. This rather than risk one man seemed reasonable to me. I got an A.
That was entirely doable. At your age, there was one thing beyond your knowledge. When making war for profit with Communists, we are NOT allowed to win. That police action in Korea was proof positive. Winning was not an option. Then along comes Vietnam and once again we do not defeat our comrades, instead make a lot of money and kill a lot of useless eaters. There seems to be a pattern there.
We should not forget that behind every "good" war these days there are always two factors; the CIA, and Drugs. Seems strange that there was opium and it's resultant products abundant in VietNam. Now we're working with the Taliban to maintain the flow of Heroin and talking about their role in governing Afgan. Also, with all of the Predator flights we can't seem to have an active eradication program? And the "illegal immigrant" "fence" is totally by the wayside? Could disturb the easy entry of drugs to the U.S. Where-ever you have the CIA, you find Drugs. Coincidence? And the Halliburton type benefits don't hurt either, huh?
I guess when you have a hammer... WTF?
The western world’s first parliament, called the Althing, was established in Iceland. It has convened every year without exception since 911 AD.
Yes we can!
The western world’s first parliament, called the Althing, was established in Iceland. It has convened every year without exception since 911 AD.
No, the Judeo-American outlook is bleak. See? For the Afghans, things are lookin' up!
"We moved into an area, secured it, at the loss of American lives and certainly Afghan lives, spending a great deal of money and making promises to civilians in the area," he said. "And then we left."
#2. To: Cynicom (#1)
#3. To: Jethro Tull (#2)
. My plan was to warn Hanoi that either they should surrender unconditionally within 72 hours, or be prepared to evacuate the city forthwith as all options were on the table.
#4. To: Cynicom, Jethro Tull (#3)
"When making war for profit with Communists, we are NOT allowed to win. That police action in Korea was proof positive. Winning was not an option. Then along comes Vietnam and once again we do not defeat our comrades, instead make a lot of money and kill a lot of useless eaters.
#5. To: Jethro Tull (#0)
a B-1 bomber destroy a mud house
#6. To: Jethro Tull (#0)
"We moved into an area, secured it, at the loss of American lives and certainly Afghan lives, spending a great deal of money and making promises to civilians in the area," he said. "And then we left."
#7. To: Jethro Tull (#0)
Afghan Outlook Bleak as Taliban Grabs Territory
As one of America's top military analysts, Anthony Cordesman, says: The U.S. "is now decisively losing."
Mike Flaherty: Yeah, it's been there a long time. I wish I knew which corner.
My Man Godfrey (1936)
#8. To: ndcorup (#4)
Got Poppy ?
"If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen.”—Samuel Adams 
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest