See other Science/Tech Articles
Title: Judge attacks nine errors in Al Gore's 'alarmist' climate change film
Source:
[None]
URL Source: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art ... rmist-climate-change-film.html
Published: Oct 16, 2009
Author: Mail Online
Post Date: 2009-10-16 10:59:25 by Jethro Tull
Keywords: None
Views: 128
Comments: 7
Last updated at 08:38 11 October 2007 A controversial documentary on climate change which has been sent to thousands of schools has been criticised by a High Court judge for being 'alarmist' and 'exaggerated'. Mr Justice Burton said former US vice-president Al Gore's film, An Inconvenient Truth, was 'one-sided' and would breach education rules unless accompanied by a warning. Despite winning lavish praise from the environmental lobby and an Oscar from the film industry, Mr Gore's documentary was found to contain 'nine scientific errors' by the judge. Scroll down for more... A High Court judge ruled Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth was 'alarmist' and 'exaggerated' These inconvenient untruths included the claim that the snows on Mount Kilimanjaro were disapearing and solely due to the global warming and that sea levels will rise up to 20 feet in the near future. Kent school governor Stewart Dimmock brought the legal action, claiming the film was unfit for schools Impressed by the film's slick message on climate change, the Government sent copies of the documentary to all secondary schools in England earlier this year, along with two short films and an animation about the carbon cycle produced by Defra. Ruling that the film could be shown in schools as part of the climate change resource pack, Mr Justice Burton warned it must be accompanied by new guidance notes to balance Mr Gore's partisan views. The High Court action was brought by a father-of-two who accused Labour of 'brainwashing' children with propaganda. Kent school governor Stewart Dimmock claimed the film was unfit for schools as it was politically partisan, containing serious scientific inaccuracies and 'sentimental mush'. Lorry driver and member of the political group, the New Party, Mr Dimmock had sought a court order to ban the documentary after the Government decided to distribute the documentary and four short films to 3,500 schools in February. Yesterday he said he was delighted with the outcome: "The film contains blatant inaccuracies. It's a political shockumentary, it's not a scientific documentary." Describing the documentary as 'a powerful, dramatically presented and highly professionally produced film', Mr Justice Burton said it was built round the 'charismatic presence' of the ex vice president 'whose crusade it now is to persuade the world of the dangers of climate change caused by global warming'. But he said it might be necessary for the Government to make clear to teaching staff that some of Mr Gore's views were not supported or promoted by the Government, and there was 'a view to the contrary'. Agreeing that Mr Gore's film was 'broadly accurate' on the subject of climate change, he found that errors had arisen in 'the context of alarmism and exaggeration'. The judge then set out nine errors in the film which went against current mainstream scientific consensus: When the judge indicated last week what his findings were likely to be, the Government updated the accompanying guidance to schools. A Government spokesperson said it was not proposing to make any further comment on the case.
Poster Comment: I thought this article was appropriate after having just finished knocking off about 1,000 pounds of Global Warming from my trees and shrubs here in scenic central PA. This is the earliest snow *ever* in this neck of the woods. So, couple this with Chicago setting a new 82 year record for cold weather, and it's safe to say the government propAgenda regarding Al Gore's cause célèbre is best left for goofballs and those who dwell on the political left.
Judge attacks nine errors in Al Gore's 'alarmist' climate change film
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#1. To: Jethro Tull (#0)
European man has progressed so far. From the center of the universe to the center of the "environment."
The western world’s first parliament, called the Althing, was established in Iceland. It has convened every year without exception since 911 AD.
Welcome to the Landscheidt minimum. More of the same over the next 30 years.
IT has a name?? Yippee :P Unfortunately
I'll likely be 6 feet under by the time this Lands**t minimum ends (but at
least I'll be warm, very, very warm)
Awww, you not that old are you? You want me to keep you warm? I'm quite the heat generator.
YES on the warm! My chronological age differs significantly from my biological age, which is that of a randy teenager. I'm proud to report all parts are in excellent working order.
pm
"This Act (the Federal Reserve Act, Dec. 23rd 1913) establishes the most gigantic trust on earth. When the President (Woodrow Wilson) signs the Bill, the invisible government of the Monetary Power will be legalised... The worst legislative crime of the ages is perpetrated by this banking and currency Bill."--Charles Lindbergh, Sr.
Mmmm makes for more heat that way!
#2. To: Jethro Tull (#0)
This is the earliest snow *ever* in this neck of the woods.
"Greenhouse gases do not act as a blanket around the earth and they do not keep the atmosphere warm. ... greenhouse gases emit more radiation than they absorb and this ongoing radiation loss tends to cool the atmosphere at between 1C and 2C per day, a fact known for more than 50 years. And yet we continue to get the simplistic explanation that greenhouse gases warm the atmosphere and so more greenhouse gases will warm the atmosphere more. No wonder the public is taken in!" --William Kininmonth, meteorologist , 1791
#3. To: farmfriend Prefrontal Vortex, all (#2)
Welcome to the Landscheidt minimum. More of the same over the
next 30 years.
#4. To: Jethro Tull (#3)
I'll likely be 6 feet under by the time this Landshit minimum ends
"Greenhouse gases do not act as a blanket around the earth and they do not keep the atmosphere warm. ... greenhouse gases emit more radiation than they absorb and this ongoing radiation loss tends to cool the atmosphere at between 1C and 2C per day, a fact known for more than 50 years. And yet we continue to get the simplistic explanation that greenhouse gases warm the atmosphere and so more greenhouse gases will warm the atmosphere more. No wonder the public is taken in!" --William Kininmonth, meteorologist , 1791
#5. To: farmfriend (#4)
#6. To: Jethro Tull (#5)
#7. To: Jethro Tull (#5)
I'm proud to report all parts are in excellent working order.
"Greenhouse gases do not act as a blanket around the earth and they do not keep the atmosphere warm. ... greenhouse gases emit more radiation than they absorb and this ongoing radiation loss tends to cool the atmosphere at between 1C and 2C per day, a fact known for more than 50 years. And yet we continue to get the simplistic explanation that greenhouse gases warm the atmosphere and so more greenhouse gases will warm the atmosphere more. No wonder the public is taken in!" --William Kininmonth, meteorologist , 1791
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest