[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help] 

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

To Judea’s Rage, Trump orders humanitarian aid to be brought into Gaza ‘as soon as possible’

Democrats Join with GOP to Overturn Gov Newsoms Ban on Gas Powered Cars

US Trade War With China

ICE Cockfighting Bust Reveals the Dark Underbelly of Bidens Border Crisis

Air Traffic Control Overhaul Announced By Trump Administration Here's What We Know

Huge win for Trump as world's second biggest carmaker relocates manufacturing to US

Rep Anna Paulina Luna Proposes to Strip Deep State Surveillance Tools by Repealing PATRIOT Act

125 Jets Clash in One of Largest Dogfights in Recent History | India Vs Pakistan

Pakistan's Chinese-made J-10 jet brought down two Indian fighter aircraft: US officials

One in 8 Israeli Soldiers Who Fought in Gaza Is Mentally Unfit to Return for Duty

Brussels Sues Five EU Countries For Failing To Enforce Digital Censorship

Trump Taps Former DA And Fox News Host For Acting D.C. U.S. Attorney: Jeanine Pirro

Airline Workers Refuse to Let Ticketholder Check In, Pull Out Phones and Cruelly Mock Him Instead

Terrifying footage reveals US militarys new suicide drone that creates its own "kill list"

The #1 BEST Remedy for Dental Plaque (TARTAR)

Kanye West's new song: "Nigga, Heil Hitler"

DHS Admits "We can't find 95% of Biden's missing kids"

"CIA and MI6 are behind the war in India & Pakistan" Larry Johnson

Whitney Webb Explains What Trump is HIDING From the Epstein Files

Need More Proof That Polls Showing Trump Underwater Are Bogus?

Treasury Secretary hints at debt restructuring (Default Next)

Chicago-born cardinal ascends to papacy, breaking centuries-old tradition

The cruelest response for the Ukrainian Armed Forces' march on Moscow:

Nearly 10,000 mercenaries take part in hostilities on Ukraines side

Jimmy Dore: Israeli Cops BEAT UP Hasidic Jews Protesting War In Gaza!

Over 500 Ukrainian drones shot down in one day Russia

Trump considering US-led Iraq-style occupation of Gaza

Filmmaker Uncovers that the Origin of the So-Called Measles Outbreak Was a Lie

UK Trade Deal Summary

WOW - Masks Off! (Candace Owens)


Sports
See other Sports Articles

Title: Temperature and CO2 feedback loop 'weaker than thought'
Source: BBC
URL Source: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/8483722.stm
Published: Jan 28, 2010
Author: Roger Harrabin
Post Date: 2010-01-28 19:34:34 by farmfriend
Ping List: *Agriculture-Environment*     Subscribe to *Agriculture-Environment*
Keywords: None
Views: 42

Temperature and CO2 feedback loop 'weaker than thought'

By Roger Harrabin
BBC environment analyst

The most alarming forecasts of natural systems amplifying the human-induced greenhouse effect may be too high, according to a new report.

The study in Nature confirms that as the planet warms, oceans and forests will absorb proportionally less CO2.

It says this will increase the effects of man-made warming - but much less than recent research has suggested.

The authors warn, though, that their research will not reduce projections of future temperature rises.

Further, they say their concern about man-made climate change remains high.

The research, from a team of scientists in Switzerland and Germany, attempts to settle one of the great debates in climate science about exactly how the Earth's natural carbon cycle will exacerbate any man-made warming.

Positive, negative

Some climate sceptics have argued that a warmer world will increase the land available for vegetation, which will in turn absorb CO2 and temper further warming. This is known as a negative feedback loop - the Earth acting to keep itself in balance.

But the Nature research concludes that any negative feedback will be swamped by positive feedback in which extra CO2 is released from the oceans and from already-forested areas.

The oceans are the world's great store of CO2, but the warmer they become, the less CO2 they can absorb. And forests dried out by increased temperatures tend to decay and release CO2 from their trees and soils.

Commenting in Nature on the new research, Hugues Goosse from the Université Catholique de Louvain in Belgium said: "In a warmer climate, we should not expect pleasant surprises in the form of more efficient uptake of carbon by oceans and land… that would limit the amplitude of future climate change".

The IPCC's fourth assessment report had a broad range of estimates as to how far natural systems would contribute to a spiral of warming. The Nature paper narrows that range to the lower end of previous estimates.

The report's lead author, David Frank from the Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research, told BBC News that many of the calculations for the IPCC assessment report did not include an integrated carbon cycle.

He said that if the results his paper were widely accepted, the overall effect on climate projections would be neutral.

"It might lead to a downward mean revision of those (climate) models which already include the carbon cycle, but an upward revision in those which do not include the carbon cycle.

"That'll probably even itself out to signify no real change in the temperature projections overall," he said.

'Comforting'

The team's calculations are based on a probabilistic analysis of climate variation between the years 1050 and 1800 - that is, before the Industrial Revolution introduced fossil carbon into the atmosphere.

Using 200,000 data points, the study - believed by Nature to be the most comprehensive of its kind so far - compared the Antarctic ice core record of trapped CO2 bubbles with so-called proxy data like tree rings, which are used to estimate temperature changes.

The most likely value among their estimates suggests that for every degree Celsius of warming, natural ecosystems tend to release an extra 7.7 parts per million of CO2 to the atmosphere (the full range of their estimate was between 1.7 and 21.4 parts per million).

This stands in sharp contrast to the recent estimates of positive feedback models, which suggest a release of 40 parts per million per degree; the team say with 95% certainty that value is an overestimate.

"This is a valuable paper that helps to constrain certain feedback components for the past," said John Schellnhuber, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research.

"However, it is probably not suited for extrapolation into the future and it does not cover the really interesting processes like anthropogenic activation of permafrost carbon or methane clathrates."

The paper will surely not be the last word in this difficult area of research, with multiple uncertainties over data sources.

"I think that the magnitude of the warming amplification given by the carbon cycle is a live issue that will not suddenly be sorted by another paper trying to fit to palaeo-data," Professor Brian Hoskins, a climate expert from Imperial College London, told BBC News.

Another crucial issue is the degree to which past trends will line up with potentially very different future scenarios.

Professor Tim Lenton from the University of East Anglia said: "It looks intriguing and comforting if they are right. The immediate problem I can see is that past variations in CO2 and temperature over the last millennium were very small, and this group are assuming that the relationship they derive from these very small variations can be extrapolated to the much larger variations in temperature we expect this century.

"We have plenty of reason to believe that the shape of the relationship may change (be nonlinear) when we 'hit the system harder'. So, I don't think they can rule out that the positive feedback from the carbon cycle could become stronger in a significantly warmer climate." Subscribe to *Agriculture-Environment*

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  



[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help]