See other 4play Articles
Title: Janis Joplin or Crystal Bowersox, who does 'Piece of My Heart' better?
Source:
Youtube.com
URL Source: [None]
Published: Apr 27, 2010
Author: Mama sox/janis joplin
Post Date: 2010-04-27 18:59:08 by Ferret
Keywords: None
Views: 947
Comments: 23
-- Current American Idol front runner Crystal Bowersox with bassist Frank May Janus joplin with Big Brother and the Holding Company poster's comment: Crystal has been compared to Janis Joplin, whom she has said heavily influenced her. She continues competing as the favorite on American Idol tonight.
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#1. To: Ferret (#0)
If Crystal could only do 1/10th the drugs that did Janis, she could be a contender. Flaming out at 27 is a bummer, however.
On the 4th of October 1970, my heart broke in a thousand pieces when Janis Joplin from Texas died. So it is nice to see her still looked upon as a musical role model. Crystal from Ohio is a diabetic, I believe she would die real fast if she tried to go the same route with heroin and Southern Comfort. I really like Crystal and of course she's a very moving performer, but there will always be only one Janis Joplin.
I wish that you could have heard her down here at a local roadside diner/pub called Threadgills, back in the day. She sang her heart out for us. (The Rose is a personal favorite film of mine.)
Even though this Janis version isn't the best one I ever heard, she is still far superior than any imitators.
#2. To: Lod (#1)
TEXT DOLPHIN To 44144
#3. To: Ferret (#2)
#4. To: Ferret (#0)
Waiting too late to oppose tyranny has always led to bloodshed.
Hair Extensions Five Towns Merrick Manhasset Roslyn Massapequa Amityville Wantagh Farmingdale East Meadow Long Island, NY
#5. To: Lod (#3)
You lucky dog you. I would indeed have loved the opportunity. Mama Sox is really developing a big stage presence at American Idol and no doubt will be one of the very successful people who have done that reality show. So, I really want to see her perform live. *Sigh* Too young to have had a crush in the realistic sense on Janis as I hadn't even started shaving when she died. And with Crystal I am the double nickle in age and would be a dirty old man to entertain such thoughts. Life sure is grand, but it also can bite the big one in many ways too. ;-)
TEXT DOLPHIN To 44144
#6. To: Ferret, 4 (#0)
quick bio -
#7. To: Critter (#4)
I agree, I've heard better too. I kinda went by the play numbers of the videos offered when I made the choice for this thread though.
TEXT DOLPHIN To 44144
#8. To: Ferret (#7)
I searched through the youtubes for a better one, but this is the only one that shows her actually singing.
Waiting too late to oppose tyranny has always led to bloodshed.
Hair Extensions Five Towns Merrick Manhasset Roslyn Massapequa Amityville Wantagh Farmingdale East Meadow Long Island, NY
#9. To: Ferret (#5)
That reminded me of this one -
Too young to have had a crush in the realistic sense on Janis as I hadn't even started shaving when she died.
#10. To: Critter (#8)
Thanks for looking. Janis is one artist I periodically troll You Tube for hoping someone has added some sweet footage on. If that ever happens, I'll give you a heads up on it.
TEXT DOLPHIN To 44144
#11. To: Lod (#9)
that song does tell hr tale alright. She told one reporter who mentioned the dangers of singing so fiercely hard that she would rather sing memorably and burn out young than to sound half as good for much longer. There will always only ever be one Janis Joplin. Grateful Dead front man Ron McKernan (Pig Pen) was someone she had a long friendship with, and he said that he was the only one of the San Francisco sound crowd she ever allowed to call her 'Tex.' She was a sweet soul who was very generous and was often exploited for free food and drinks at night clubs by people who would feel she was rich enough to leave the tab with. She was famous and knew many people, but sometime fame can be one's worst enemy.
TEXT DOLPHIN To 44144
#12. To: Ferret (#11)
one more that speaks to Janis -
#13. To: Ferret (#0)
deleted
The relationship between morality and liberty is a directly proportional one.
"You've got to put right and wrong above legal and illegal. Because when tyranny becomes law, rebellion becomes duty; and it is not rebellion at all, it is submission to the higher law that our government is in rebellion to. We're not the rebels, they're the rebels."
#14. To: Ferret (#0)
Good Lord Mike what a silly question. You were there, guy. Joplin by a mile.
#15. To: Jethro Tull (#14)
Let Crystal try this one and I think the difference becomes more clear!
" Arguing on the internet is like running in the special olympics................................ Even if you win, you're still retarded ":
"US government debt is a safe haven the way Pearl Harbor was a safe haven in 1941."
#16. To: Hmmmmm (#15)
A huge no shit, and quote of the decade there. Many thanks.
" Arguing on the internet is like running in the special olympics................................ Even if you win, you're still retarded "
#17. To: Hmmmmm (#15)
Word. And these were done after a full day of Jack & Coke. Goodness gracious, there was some great music pumped out during that decade.
#18. To: Jethro Tull, Janis fans, 4 (#17)
She was amazing.
#19. To: All (#18)
#20. To: Ferret, All (#11)
Melissa Ethridge (she's a favorite of mine) Take a Piece of My Heart
A free man owns his own labor
#21. To: christine (#20)
Very, very, nice. But everyone who covers Janis, tries to sound like her, and comes up a bit short, no matter how well they do it. imo
#22. To: Lod (#21)
hot, hot, hot
A free man owns his own labor
#23. To: christine, 4 (#22)
here's one of my favorites for lovers in the past -
she's smoking, all right!
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest