Comment #: 10065
Rating:3.5
Comments:
Bolton is a nightmare. She is churlish, mercurial, and lazy. She fails to rule on pretrial motions, then denies them after a verdict. Her pro-Government bias is palpable.

Comment #: 9984
Rating:1.0
Comments:
Susan R. Bolton is by far THE WORST judge that I have ever seen. A pro se litigant doesn't have a chance in her courtroom. She allows the opposition (attorneys) to get away with breaking every rule in the book. She is clearly biased and, at the very least, needs to be sanctioned.

Comment #: 9792
Rating:2.5
Comments:
Horrible judge who makes her mind up one day one and contorts the facts to support her own biased opinions. Appeal her every time you can to the Ninth Circuit and maybe they will know via her reversal rate she is incompetant. Shame om Kyl and Clinton for giving us this level of ineptitude. Not qualified to be a JP

Comment #: 9196
Rating:1.0
Comments:
Susan Boilton makes wrongful judgments unsuitable for a federal judge that tend to undermine confidence in the judiciary.

Comment #: 8540
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
The worst. She dismissed an action litigated for 18 months for lack of federal jurisdiction. We prevailed on appeal, but thereafter settled because she let it be known that she was going to ensure that an alum from her law school ultimately prevail. She is dismissive of counsel, intemperate and biased. The worst in the District of Arizona and an example why Article III should be amended to require direct and periodic election of district judges.

Comment #: 7863
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Judge Susan R. Bolton picks her favorite side based on her interest and then contorts her findings to fit her desired outcome. She is devoid of intellectual honesty. She makes wrongful judgments unsuitable for a federal judge that tend to undermine confidence in the judiciary.

Comment #: 7852
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
I was shocked by Judge Bolton’s rulings in the civil cases. Surely if the Ninth Circuit had access to everything that goes on in the cases. they would be shocked to know how Judge Bolton is actually handling litigation and her reversal rating would be worse. Her rulings are outrageous. Judge Bolton makes up her mind before hearing the facts. There is some disconnect between this judge and reality. She likes to listen to one side of parties. She uses her own speculation to defend one side of parties. Judge Bolton is imperious, biased, arrogant, sarcastic and inappropriate and should be sanctioned.