[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help] 

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Woman points gun at police and finds out

EXCLUSIVE: Rep. Ronny Jackson Accuses Biden Doctor Kevin O’Connor Of Sexual Misconduct

WHAT YOU’RE WITNESSING IN LOS ANGELES ISN’T JUST UNREST—IT’S MORAL COLLAPSE

Anna Paulina Luna Exposes the Guy Behind the Anti-ICE Riots

Mike Huckabee Working To Keep Netanyahu in Power

Israeli Military and Israeli-Backed Gang Shoot Aid Seekers in Gaza, Killing 14

Only 68 Building Permits Issued for Pacific Palisades After Wildfires Destroyed 6800 Structures

Violent Rioters Fire Off Exploding Projectiles at Police Horses Use Fireworks and Explosives to Attack Police

ICE Just Shattered Records With One Massive Operation That Has Democrats Fuming

Nolte: Insurrectionist Democrats Plan Another Summer of Blue City-Riots

Violent riots have now been reported in over 30 American cities. Heres a full list:

Mass shooter opened fire at graduation party was an migrant who was busted in LA ICE raids:

Cash Jordan: ICE Raids Home Depot... as California Collapses

Silver Is Finally Soaring: Here's Why

New 4um Interface Coming Soon

Attack of the Dead-2025.

Canada strips Jewish National Fund of charitable status

Minnesota State Rep. Vang just admitted that she is an ILLEGAL ALIEN.

1100% increase in neurological events since the roll-out of Covid mRNA

16 Things That Everyone Needs To Know About Violent Far-Left Revolution In Los Angeles

Undercover video in Arizona alleges ongoing consumer fraud by Fairlife

Dozens arrested after San Francisco protest turns violent Sunday

Looking for the toughest badasses in the city (Los Angeles)

Democrat Civil War Explodes: DNC Chair Threatens to Quit Over David Hogg

Invaders waving Mexican flags, pour onto the 101 Freeway in Los Angeles

Australian Fake News Journo Hit By Rubber Bullet In L.A. Riot

22-year-old dies after being unable to afford asthma inhaler

North Korean Bulsae-4 Long-Range ATGM Spotted Again In Russian Operation Zone

Alexander Dugin: A real Maidan has begun in Los Angeles

State Department Weighing $500 Million Grant to Controversial Gaza Aid Group: Report


History
See other History Articles

Title: TRUTH ABOUT GHORBANIFAR
Source: The New York Review of Books
URL Source: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/4049
Published: Apr 27, 1989
Author: Michael A. Ledeen, Reply by Theodore H.
Post Date: 2005-11-12 00:29:22 by Dakmar
Keywords: GHORBANIFAR, TRUTH, ABOUT
Views: 56
Comments: 4

In response to 'Rewriting the Iran-Contra Story': An Exchange

To the Editors:

Theodore Draper is really an amazing phenomenon: he is so intent on discrediting my book, Perilous Statecraft, that he sinks to new lows in misdirection [Letters, NYR, March 2] when he discovers that I agree with him. How else can one explain his denunciation of me for daring to point out that we agree that Casey almost surely was not the inspiration for North's "off the shelf" covert action program and the "diversion" of money from the Iran Initiative to the contras? He even savages me for quoting Casey's lawyer in support of (not, as Draper would have it, "to prove") that conclusion (which is argued over a number of pages).

Then he has at me once again on Ghorbanifar. Like those at CIA who stereotyped Ghorbanifar as a near-total, pathological liar, Draper just can't bring himself to look honestly at the evidence. For what does Mr. Draper use as proof of Ghorbanifar's mendacity? He cites the trip to Tehran in the spring of 1986, when "Ghorbanifar was blamed by the Americans for having deceived both sides about what each was prepared to do…."

It sounds good, but it's wrong, as Draper should have learned by reading Perilous Statecraft, or by simple logic. For if the Americans really believed Ghorbanifar to be a liar, how could they have entrusted the arrangements for a trip as sensitive as the Tehran mission to such a person? They couldn't, and they didn't. The arrangements were confirmed in two separate telephone conversations between the CIA's George Cave, and two top officials of the Khomeini regime in Tehran. So whatever misunderstandings existed can't fairly be blamed on Ghorbanifar (as North did in his public testimony). And indeed, Cave testified to the Iran-Contra committees that his understanding of the arrangements did not coincide with what North apparently told McFarlane.

So Draper's bullying words about me—"Michael A. Ledeen is a gambler. He gambles that no one is going to check up on him"—are better applied to himself.

Michael A. Ledeen Chevy Chase, Maryland

Theodore Draper replies:
Whether he likes it or not, Mr. Ledeen is still gambling:

1. The point at issue in Ledeen's citation of a statement by Milton Gould, William Casey's lawyer, is whether it referred to Casey's attitude toward the "off-the-shelf capability." I showed that Gould had said nothing more than that Casey had never done anything wrong. Ledeen again falls back on Gould without being able to cite anything to the contrary. If Ledeen could point to anything in Gould's statement that actually refers to the "off-the-shelf capability," he should have put it in his present letter. Bluster is not good enough.

2. More important is the issue whether Ghorbanifar lied to both sides at key moments—something Ledeen explicitly denied in his book (pp. 192–193). Now Ledeen mentions the evidence given by George Cave, the Farsi-speaking CIA consultant who went on the mission to Tehran. Cave happens to be the one who has given the most telling testimony that Ghorbanifar deceived both sides.

On p. 627 of his deposition, Cave states that Ghorbanifar told the Americans that they would meet with Prime Minister Musavi, Speaker of the Majlis Rafsanjani, and President Khomeini. The Americans were never permitted to meet them. On p. 652, Cave relates that the "senior Iranian" at Tehran "got me aside and showed me letters Ghorbanifar had written, giving them all this stuff that we had never heard about…. It is clear Ghorbanifar was telling the Iranian side one thing and us another."

It is also clear that Ledeen has not done his homework and is gambling that no one else is doing it.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: robin, Zipporah, rowdee, aristeides, BTP Holdings, tom007 (#0)

Note the date, this is from 1989. These guys are why Plame, Brewster, Jennings, were shut down.

And I'm optimistic. See, I think you can be realistic and optimistic at the same time. I'm optimistic we'll achieve -- I know we won't achieve if we send mixed signals. I know we're not going to achieve our objective if we send mixed signals - gwbush

Dakmar  posted on  2005-11-12   0:34:35 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: SKYDRIFTER (#1)

Ledeen is a menace ping.

And I'm optimistic. See, I think you can be realistic and optimistic at the same time. I'm optimistic we'll achieve -- I know we won't achieve if we send mixed signals. I know we're not going to achieve our objective if we send mixed signals - gwbush

Dakmar  posted on  2005-11-12   0:47:19 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: Dakmar (#1)

Thanks.. I tried to read 'Rewriting the Iran-Contra Story': An Exchange'..what was linked but you can only read it for $$ .. very interesting.

Fallujah, The Hidden Massacre

Zipporah  posted on  2005-11-12   11:32:26 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#4. To: Dakmar (#1)

Verrry interesting.

Note tht #2 above mentions 'Farsi-speaking'........the only other time I've ever heard this word, Farsi, has been in relation to Sibel Edmunds, the FBI translation whistleblower.

Wonder if there can be some sort of link in that bottle of mess.

rowdee  posted on  2005-11-12   11:39:35 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help]