[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help] 

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Why is Putin's back against the wall? First Lady Melania Trump's Full Interview on Fox & Friends Online site tells you how much Kamala Harris presidency will cost you Trump's Best Kamala Ad US warships under attack in Red Sea as 'barrage' of Houthi missiles rain down Biden and Harris to Offer $153 Million in Awards for States That Adopt Pre-Crime Gun Confiscation Laws Taxpayer-funded Minneapolis food pantry bans white people Another Gulf Hurricane for Sunday Oct 6. Same Area as Helene Lebanon Will Make Israel Regret Its Actions, Iran's Supreme Leader Warns 54 People Rescued from Roof of Hospital in Tennessee Due to Flood Caused by Hurricane Helene Germany faces economic DISASTER, as Social Democrats drive country into the ground Warning! Biggest Silver Short Position Recorded - Ed Steer Silver Price Prediction Kroger was pretty slim pickin's today Kunstler: America Is "A Headless Horseman Riding Blindly Into Chaos" Ohio Dem Senator To Hold Event With Group Pushing To Close States Largest Coal Plant Kamala Harris campaign’s internal polls reveal devastating losses in Georgia, North Carolina, Arizona. Kamala Harris campaign’s internal polls reveal devastating losses in Georgia, North Carolina, Arizona. Sea Port STRIKES Happening October 1st!! (We KNEW IT!!!) | Buddy Brown NYC Mayor Eric Adams Claims He's Being Targeted by Biden for Defending New Yorkers Against Illegal Aliens What are Israel's goals in Lebanon? Israeli military build-up near the Lebanese border. Human remains found at McDonald’s meat supplier by the FBI. Kamala was caught using actors pretending to be ex-Trump supporters in her ads! Venezuelan Gang Infiltrates Migrant Shelters to Build Criminal Empire in NYC Are US Troops Combat Ready for Israel? Now that's an edit - Russian Power Shirley Temple On How Hollywood Is Run by Pedophiles The UN Just Adopted The Pact For The Future Which Lays The Foundation For A New Global Order Vermont State Police Detain O'Keefe Over Questions About Cease-and-Desist Letter to Whistleblower Kamala Harris repeats vague talking points with little substance in softball MSNBC interview

Editorial
See other Editorial Articles

Title: Why Americans don't understand the Middle East
Source: [None]
URL Source: [None]
Published: Sep 16, 2012
Author: http://walt.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2012
Post Date: 2012-09-16 15:23:06 by tom007
Keywords: None
Views: 44

Why Americans don't understand the Middle East Posted By Stephen M. Walt Friday, September 14, 2012 - 11:25 AM Share

I hardly ever watch network news, but I happened to stumble across this appalling report on NBC's "Rock Center" last night. In this clip, reporter Richard Engel blames this week's anti-American violence on "conspiracy theories" that Arab populations have been fed over the years by their rulers, including the idea that the United States and Israel are colluding to control the Middle East.

It's no secret there are conspiracy theories circulating in the Middle East (as there are here in the good old USA: Remember the "birthers?") I've heard them every time I've lectured in the region and done my best to debunk them. But by attributing Arab and Muslim anger solely to these ideas, Engel's report paints a picture of the United States (and by implication, Israel) as wholly blameless. In his telling, the U.S. has had nothing but good intentions for the past century, but the intended beneficiaries of our generosity don't get it solely because they've been misled by their leaders.

In short, Operation Cast Lead never happened, Lebanon wasn't invaded in 1982 or bombed relentlessly for a month in 2006, the United States has never turned a blind eye towards repeated human rights violations by every single one of its Middle Eastern allies, drones either don't exist or never killed an innocent victim, the occupation of Iraq in 2003 was just a little misunderstanding, and the Palestinians ought to be grateful to us for what they've been left after forty-plus years of occupation. To say this in no way absolves governments in the region for responsibility for many of their current difficulties, but Americans do themselves no favors by ignoring our own contribution to the region's ills.

In short, you want to get some idea of why most Americans have no idea why we are unpopular in the region, this example of sanitized "analysis" is illuminating, though not in the way that Engel and NBC intended.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help]