[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help] 

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Cash Jordan: ICE deploys strike teams to NYC

ITV pulling zero punches in this incredible footage

Nurse Blows Whistle on Cover-Up of 5000% Surge in Fetal Deaths Caused by Covid Vaccines

Matt Taibbi Obliterates Dean Of Columbia Journalism School In Open Letter

Southern Kamchatka shifted nearly two meters (6 1/2 feet) After 8.8 Megaquake

Cash Sent Home By Mexicans Craters 16.2% In June As More Immigrants Leave US Workforce

Lefties Losing It: Trump shocks journalists with rooftop walk

Things Just Got a WHOLE LOT WORSE for Jack Smith ….

Black Democrat SHOCKS Party and FLIPS RED!!!

Arson Attack Hits ICE Field Office In Washington State Amid Dangerous Rhetoric From Democrats

One Chart To Kill The Medicaid Lies For Good

Hang on! Now Ukraine is recruiting 14-year-olds to fight NATO's proxy war?

RED MOON

Dr Horse's Systolic Blood Pressure is 116 at last reading

JAG ARRESTS BIDEN OPERATIVE FOR TREASON AFTER ECONOMIC FRAUD EXPOSED

mRNA Vaccines Have Destroyed Immune Systems of Millions. Renowned Toxicologist

Insane MASSACRE in NIKOLAEV: RUSSIA Attacked 'OCEAN' Shipyard full of FRENCH Soldiers and Officers

“It’s Demonic” - Candace Goes All In on Epstein and Israel

The Secret Payments That Keep Global Ransomware Attacks Going

The Whopping Lie Behind Huge, New Pension Liability Imposed By Springfield On Chicago

Families Are Fascist

"Operation Gladio is Alive and Well" NATO"s secret terrorist army EXPOSED

White Swan Collapse Underway: Ed Dowd Warns 50% Stock Crash

To Kill An Operation Mockingbird: Tulsi Goes To War With The CIA's Propaganda Yobbos

Huge Drug And Weapons Haul In French Polynesia Echoes Kash Patel's Warnings

⚠️ALERT: TRUMP HAS ACTIVATED 11.3 – Law Of War Manual

IDF Soldier: “We Were ORDERED To Stand Down On October 7th!”

Michael Snyder: The New York Declaration” Could Potentially Change Everything

Hillary Clinton calls for the repeal of Section 230 so that platforms can moderate Americans' speech.

Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans - Outrage AI Parody Song


Editorial
See other Editorial Articles

Title: Politicians and police don't deserve special treatment.
Source: USA Today
URL Source: http://www.usatoday.com/story/opini ... als-privileges-column/2696945/
Published: Aug 26, 2013
Author: G.H. Reynolds
Post Date: 2013-08-29 17:40:45 by X-15
Keywords: None
Views: 268
Comments: 2

All over America, government officials enjoy privileges that ordinary citizens don't. Sometimes it involves bearing arms, with special rules favoring police, politicians and even retired government employees. Sometimes it involves freedom from traffic and parking tickets, like the special non-traceable license plates enjoyed by tens of thousands of California state employees or similar immunities for Colorado legislators. Often it involves immunity from legal challenges, like the "qualified" immunity to lawsuits enjoyed by most government officials, or the even-better "absolute immunity" enjoyed by judges and prosecutors. (Both immunities -- including, suspiciously, the one for judges -- are creations of judicial action, not legislation).

Lately it seems as if these kinds of special privileges are proliferating. And it also seems to me that special privileges for "public servants" that have the effect of making them look more like, well, "public masters," are kind of un-American. Even more, I'm beginning to wonder if they might actually be unconstitutional. Surely the creation of two classes of citizens, one more equal than the others, isn't the sort of thing the Framers intended. Why didn't they put something in the Constitution to prevent it?

Well, actually, they did. Article I, Section 9 of the Constitution prohibits the federal government from granting "titles of nobility," and Article I, Section 10 extends this prohibition to the states -- one of the few provisions in the original Constitution to impose limits directly on states. Surely the Framers must have considered this prohibition pretty important.

Well, yes. But since then we've read it rather narrowly: Basically, so long as people aren't granted titles like Baron, Duke, or Sir, nobody even considers the question of titles of nobility. And, of course, the kinds of privileges I describe aren't hereditary (and though the growth of political dynasties like the Bushes and the Clintons should give people pause, it doesn't rise to the level of titles of nobility -- does it?). But in England they have Life Peerages as Barons that aren't hereditary, and the titles of nobility clause also forbids American officials from accepting knighthoods, which aren't hereditary, from foreign nations without consent of Congress. So the ban on titles of nobility can't just be a matter of word-games, or descent.

There hasn't been much judicial action on the titles of nobility clause -- they are, as described in Prof. Jay Wexler's book of the same name, among the Constitution's "odd clauses." But since we always hear that the Constitution is a "living, breathing document" that must change to adapt to the times, perhaps in this era of big government and accumulating special privileges it is time to give the ban on titles of nobility a second look.

How would I do it? I'd provide that any rule giving government officials -- whether elected, appointed, or members of the civil service -- preferential treatment compared to ordinary citizens would have to withstand "strict scrutiny." That is, I'd treat discrimination based on government employment status the same way we currently treat racial discrimination. To withstand strict scrutiny, a government action must serve a "compelling government interest," and must be narrowly tailored to serve that interest. And there must be no less restrictive means of achieving the same goal. That would be especially true where the distinctions -- special privileges relating to legal process, or the right to bear arms, for example -- parallel those enjoyed by the nobility in the Framing era.

Applying this to distinctions between government employees and citizens would undoubtedly knock down a lot of those distinctions. But, in my opinion, that wouldn't be so bad. Frankly, our political class seems to have gotten a little full of itself.

Is this too much "living, breathing" Constitution for you? Well, okay, but it's less of a stretch than we've seen in other areas of constitutional interpretation, such as the Commerce Clause. And it addresses a real problem: The growth not only of government, but of a governing class that believes, in a very real way, that it is fundamentally above the law.

Address this my way, or some other way. But one way or another, it's likely to be addressed. At least my way doesn't involve pitchforks.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: X-15 (#0)

In my city they have taken to giving certain school staff public cars with exempt plates. Why is the Superintendent exempt of obeying traffic laws? Because in this tyranny public servants ARE parading around as public masters .

I don't say that this is a freaking tyranny to be repetitive but rather because that is the upsetting facts currently

______________________________________

Suspect all media / resist bad propaganda/Learn NLP everyday everyway ;) (It's a more positive message)

titorite  posted on  2013-08-29   18:23:10 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: X-15, All (#0)

Politicians and police don't deserve special treatment.

Re: "titles of nobility" and whatnot...

Activists propose naming hurricanes after US politicians

The video is full of mock news with headlines

A good idea that shouldn't be restricted to the issue of "Climate Change".

-------

"They're on our left, they're on our right, they're in front of us, they're behind us...they can't get away this time." -- Col. Puller, USMC

GreyLmist  posted on  2013-08-29   19:35:39 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help]