See other Miscellaneous Articles
Title: Would You (doctor) Ever Date a Patient?
Source:
[None]
URL Source: [None]
Published: Sep 26, 2013
Author: Brandon Cohen
Post Date: 2013-09-26 01:27:31 by Tatarewicz
Keywords: None
Views: 127
Comments: 6
Medscape... The sensitive topic of doctor-patient romance heated up a recent all-physician discussion on Medscape Connect. The conversation ranged from general ethical warnings to specific forms of temptation, as doctors bravely explored some delicate areas. A dermatologist began the discussion with personal history and a question: "Since I stopped wearing my wedding band about a year ago, more of my patients have increased interest in me. Just out of curiosity, how many of you have dated active patients or former patients?" Several colleagues were clear and firm in their opposition to these kinds of associations. An internist framed the dilemma in contrasting lists: "Reasons to date a patient: fleeting excitement. Reasons to never date anybody you have a physician relationship with: your license, your reputation, your license, unhealthy psychodynamics, your license, STDs, your license." Another internist found the answer self-evident: "I think everyone should know that we lose objectivity and the ability to provide care when we enter into an intimate or romantic situation with patients... it is IMPROPER." Others had strong opinions but made a distinction between current and former patients. "NO, NO, NO," intoned a genomic medicine specialist. "Discharge them from your practice. Then see what happens. If they are still interested, ask away. If they are not still interested, then they may have been looking for a lottery ticket." A surgeon added, "A physician dating a patient is a lot like smoking while pumping gas. I've seen people do it with no problem, but it carries a high risk of unpleasant (and permanent) consequences." Other physicians went back to Ancient Greece to bolster their arguments. "Since the time of Hippocrates this has been a no-no," wrote a pediatrician. A primary care physician agreed and offered the relevant quote: "'Whatever houses I may visit, I come for the benefit of the sick, remaining free of all intentional injustice, of all mischief and in particular of sexual relations.' And there's the rub in this oath we take." But some did not feel bound by a pledge to Apollo and saw glimmers of hope for doctor-patient unions: "My previous boss married his psoriasis patient," brightly offered a dermatologist. "So much temptation, so little time! Sometimes one wonders what is gained or lost when one is cautious, serious, dignified, upstanding," wondered an internist, dismissing the caution of many colleagues. A primary care physician went even further. "Up until the 1990s, dating patients or even marrying them wasn't at all that uncommon," he wrote, and he went on to reject the caution of colleagues as a "[projection of] the anger of or your envy onto those of us who did [date patients] back in those Golden Days of American Medicine." But an orthopedic surgeon quickly responded: "I am not jealous. I could have so many girlfriends, it is scary. I choose to avoid them." Many other physicians picked up on the idea that it is a difficult road for the attractive physician because of so many potential suitors. An internist claimed to have been "hit on like Normandy beach." And a dermatologist mentioned that female patients have provocatively left red panties in the examination room or asked him to go on motorcycle rides. Ultimately, most of these heartthrobs came to the decision that it was not worth the risk of damaging one's professionalism. One internist, while understanding the temptation, argued against pursuing patients because there are so many other available options: "I don't think it is difficult to find interested companions for just about any activity. Bars are still full of desperate people seeking inappropriate connections. The Internet is funded largely on unchecked libido. If one is looking for [sexual partners], why risk the problems of patient relationship issues?" And another internist questioned the basic pleasures of such risky relationships: "Imagine the consequence of marrying or dating a patient; likely you will be practicing your trade every minute...after a long day in the office." A survey on Medscape found that 68% of physicians believed that it was never ethical to date a patient, even if the patient had been discharged. The original poster, seeking a more official standard, provided the guidelines of the American Medical Association (AMA) on the topic: Sexual contact that occurs concurrent with the patient-physician relationship constitutes sexual misconduct.... Sexual or romantic relationships with former patients are unethical if the physician uses or exploits trust, knowledge, emotions, or influence derived from the previous professional relationship.[1] An internist was even more austere than the AMA: "As soon as a patient is examined by a physician in your office, you establish a physician-patient relationship. That relationship ideally is sacred, and if one is turned on by an attractive patient during such an encounter in the office, your options are to either discharge the patient or ALWAYS have a chaperone." The final word goes to a primary care physician, presumably with some experience in gerontology, who quipped, "I use carbon-14 to date some of my patients." The full discussion of this topic is available at http://boards.medscape.com/forums/.2a590fef. Please note that this is open to physicians only.
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#1. To: Tatarewicz, X-15, Original_Intent (#0)
Doctor Jones had slept with one of his patients and felt guilty all day long. No matter how much he tried to forget about it, he just couldn't. The guilt and sense of betrayal was overwhelming. But every once in a while he'd hear an internal, reassuring voice in his head that said: "John, don't worry about it. You aren't the first medical practitioner to sleep with one of their patients and you won't be the last. And you're single. Just let it go, John." But invariably another voice in his head would bring him back to reality, whispering: "John.............................. John..................... John......... You're a Veterinarian, you sick bastard!" A study group recently released its findings as to the best presidents of the United States of America. Obama has been rated as the 4th best president ever: Reagan and 9 others tied for first, 15 presidents tied for second, 18 tied for third, and Obama came in fourth. There are similar concerns about lawyers dating their clients, but, several years ago, one young woman lawyer in a big firm justified it by saying "My legal practice keeps me so busy that I don't have time to go to singles bars or mixers. The only people I know are other lawyers in my firm and my clients. And I wouldn't touch the other lawyers with a barge pole."
That's disgusting - I like it. :-) "“Believe nothing merely because you have been told it. Do not believe what your teacher tells you merely out of respect for the teacher. But whatsoever, after due examination and analysis, you find to be kind, conducive to the good, the benefit, the welfare of all beings - that doctrine believe and cling to, and take it as your guide.” ~ Gautama Siddhartha — The Buddha This one was easy for me. As a female physician, I got to watch my male unmarried(and married) peers being relentlessly pursued by women desiring their Mrs degree. In med school, a nearby sorority put our class picture in their dining room and planned to cross out each male face after being snared. I was only pursued by really strange patients. One guy wanted me to examine his eyes in the dark and then presented me with a buckskin brassiere. The rule that physicians do not have intimate relations with patients is ancient. The best physician patient relationship is both intimate(I don't mean sex) in that a physician must feel free to enter into a patients' personal space and enter their body at times(I believe I've had my finger up a lot of......) and yet a professional distance must be maintained at the same time. There are formal proceedures to follow if a doc falls in love with a patient. This can happen easily when the only doctor in a small rural town is unmarried and virtually everyone they encounter is a patient. The doc then needs to first end the professional relationship formally, then wait six months to start the personal relationship. It is best to formally notify the state medical association as well. There is no excuse for crossing this line.
I'm not a doctor, although I've played one, and the answer to the question is a definite maybe.
Ahahahaha!!!
#2. To: Tatarewicz (#0)
#3. To: farmfriend (#1)
You're a Veterinarian, you sick bastard!"
Any sufficiently advanced stupidity is indistinguishable from evil. ~ Unk (Paraphrase of Clarke's 3rd Law: "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.")
#4. To: Tatarewicz (#0)
#5. To: Tatarewicz (#0)
#6. To: farmfriend (#1)
-Alex Kurtagic
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest