[Home] [Headlines] [Latest Articles] [Latest Comments] [Post] [Sign-in] [Mail] [Setup] [Help] [Register]
Status: Not Logged In; Sign In
Immigration See other Immigration Articles Title: Leading 'La Marcha' Leading 'La Marcha' Rinku Sen is the publisher of ColorLines magazine and communications director of the Applied Research Center (ARC). Last month, hundreds of thousands of immigrants marched to protest Rep. James F. Sensenbrenners, R-Wis., punitive immigration bill. Five hundred thousand marched in Los Angeles, 100,000 in Chicago, and 50,000 in Denver. Similar numbers are expected today . The protests have touched many more than even those numbers imply. Millions of peopleat kitchen tables, in bars, at the bowling alleyare now debating the rights of immigrants, particularly Latinos, to assert themselves as Americans while holding to their original identities. These developments appear to have killed the House bill. Whether or not a better bill passes this year, theres no question that the immigration policy debate has shifted. These events offer important lessons for advocates and policymakers. Strategically, the protests have exposed the true nature of the immigration debate, which is far more cultural and racial than our economic arguments have accounted for. Tactically, they teach us that social networks and media have to be integrated with our political strategy, even though they cannot, by their very nature, be fully predicted or controlled. The immigration debate has largely pitted two images of undocumented immigrants against each other. On the political right, they are lawbreakers. On the left, they are hard workers. Conservatives are careful not to appear racist by focusing on legal technicalities. Progressives have also been silent on race because they fear that immigrants dont see themselves as people of color, or because they want to pander to Americans who cant stomach the idea that their nation is growing browner with every passing year. For many years, the right and left have been talking in codes around the real issue. Americans, whether corporate leader or working mother, are perfectly fine having brown people from other countries provide cheap labor. But they draw the line at letting those people bring or build families here, and at letting them speak other languages or marry their children. The look and feel of the demonstrations indicates that these racial and cultural dynamics has driven the debate into the streets. A New America Media poll reveals that the vast majority of legal immigrants are alarmed by the racism embedded in the debate. This is an uprising of people, not just of workers, who are social beings rather than economic objects. Hundreds of thousands of marchers are now telling America what its leaders have kept quiet: you cant have our labor without changing the color of the country. Immigrants, legal or not, will change the complexion and culture of the United States within the next 50 years. The controversy over protestors carrying Mexican and Central American flags proves the point. The criticism from conservative ideologues and liberal tacticians isnt going to change the reality of a multiracial, multilingual, multinational America. Its because of the racial identity base of the protestors that these marches have so much focusthe kind of focus that similarly massive anti-war protests, which have included everything from Palestine to global warming, have lacked. This explosive movement has been driven by social, rather than by political, networks. In fact, every U.S. social movement has reached its apex when the political and social elements came together, when they had the political base, used the mass media creatively and effectively, and activated friendship, spiritual and family networks. While immigrant rights organizations have worked for years to generate mass action on a range of anti-immigrant ballot measures in California, the convergence of distinct cultural trends has made all the difference. Young people are moving their friends through cell phones and MySpace, Spanish-language radio DJs (in the corporate media, by the way) are talking to their listeners, and church leaders, both lay and ordained, are getting to their parishioners. Certainly, unions and immigrant rights groups are also activating their members, but lets face it, these kinds of numbers are generated virally and many thousands of people who show up to these protests will never join an organization. The activity is decentralized. No single organization or coalition owns it. Therefore, it cant be fully directed and its a bit unpredictable. The organized chaos of social movements often frightens advocates who spend most of their time trying to get legislative cooperation. This doesnt mean that organizations and policies are irrelevant to movement building. Movements rise from the foundation of organizing, policy development and community leadership so that when the public eye moves around looking for the truth, theres somewhere for it to land. While this mobilization has been driven by a web of intimate associations it is the political organizing across generations that has pushed politicians to take up the immigration debate. Without this kind of persistent political activity, there would be no immigration policy to challenge; and no alternative to the increasingly punitive immigration policies. People tend to rise up over specific threats that represent a larger systemsomeone has to agitate anger over that threat and raise the publics expectations for better policy. Thats what immigrant rights organizations and their allies have been doing over the last 15 years. Todays events show us again how focused mass movement emerges from social networks and media, then changes public opinion, which then puts new pressure on policy makers. Innovative organizations equip themselves to deal with social networks and the media, not just when something big needs to happen, but all the time. As a friend said to me over dinner after organizing 100,000 marchers in D.C., You work on immigration for 10 years, and then all of a sudden your moment comes. It almost killed us, but we were ready. The only way to get ready is to build social activity and media work into our programs and products. Progressive funders, however, constantly ask advocates and organizations to prove that our work results in policy change. Theyd like us to draw a straight line between our activities and the change we seek, year after year, and theyd like us to walk down that line quickly. The fact that social movements that feed truly large scale policy change doesnt work that way wouldnt be so unfortunate if progressive elites werent so attached to that idea, forcing the flow of resources into very narrow channels. Something important is happening today. Its showing us that we have to talk about race because that is what the policy debateand the reality of peoples livesis really about. Its also showing us that we have to lay the foundation to ride a spontaneous movement when it does arrive. In these high moments, we also have to remember that no individual movement is successful forever, that all victories generate a backlash. So its important not to over-exceptionalize the immigrant rights movement, to recognize that its real strength will be in its broader lessons for advocates and in its broader moral resonance for all people of color, and indeed, for all Americans.
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread Top Page Up Full Thread Page Down Bottom/Latest
#1. To: Tauzero (#0)
I would cancel my subscription if the author worked for the paid media. I have been listening to a local Pacifica radio station because I cannot get the truth about Iraq and Palestine from the corporate media. This morning I heard guests on the local news being interviewed about la marcha. They allowed 2 callers to ask questions. Both were black. And both said black people were being left out of this discussion. One of the women being interviewed said that some congressmen were getting 300 calls against amnesty for every 1 favoring it. She urged people to call their cogressmen. This shows that a broad spectrum of whites and blacks, who are not comatose and not racists, oppose amnesty. Why would they oppose what their Rep and Dem leaders in the Senate favor? How about wages? How about high priced housing in areas with tons of illegal aliens? How about 500,000 illegal aliens in our federal prisons? How about 100,000s criminals in Mexico with outstanding warrants in the U.S? Let me say this again: The only reason our standard of living is so high is that we print dollars that are worthless and receive cars, TVs, computers, food, and everything at WalMart for FREE. Currently, Asians are willing to sit on 2 trillion dollars in worthless American paper dollars. And they are willing to accept 850 billion dollars a year more of worthless paper. When they refuse paper and accept only gold or Euros or Yen or Yuan, then we will balance our trade deficit by cutting wages by at least %50. We will cut pensions and savings by %90. ANYONE who favors amnesty wants to cut wages by more than 50% and pensions by more than 90%. That is the end of the argument for rational people who use only authentic arguments. This is not about anyone's feelings. This is not about race. It is about America surviving this decade. We have less than 4 years to go. It is debatable that we survive in any recognizable form that long.
A white America like that of the 30s could easily survive all those things.
We are suffering from other factors as well. We are way overpopulated. Wages will have to be cut to accommodate all the new immigrants. But liberalism tells them to demand a standard of living we can no longer afford. And we suffer from 70 years of cultural Marxism which has destroyed the culture that bonded white people from many nations into one. Now we are just consumers trying to keep up with our payments. The whole thing will crash before the end of 2009. When it does, you do not want to live near any American city.
I hear ya.
|
||
[Home]
[Headlines]
[Latest Articles]
[Latest Comments]
[Post]
[Sign-in]
[Mail]
[Setup]
[Help]
[Register]
|