See other Dead Constitution Articles
Title: Torture, the Law of the Land - and The Torture Mastermind Reviewed
Source:
Bovard
URL Source: http://jimbovard.com/blog/2006/09/2 ... e-torture-mastermind-reviewed/
Published: Sep 22, 2006
Author: James Bovard
Post Date: 2006-09-23 06:32:08 by hammerdown
Keywords: Bush, Senate, Yoo
Views: 131
Comments: 10
The key players in the U.S. Senate have agreed with the Bush administration to retroactively legalize torture by U.S. government agents. The compromise deal struck yesterday will block prosecution for CIA officials who tortured detainees since 9/11. I would expect that, in the name of “fair play,” someone will begin pushing similar legislation to give immunity to U.S. military officials who tortured detainees in Afghanistan and Iraq. The legislative “compromise” blocks detainees from suing in federal court after they have been tortured. Game, set, match. And it is worse than naive for Americans to comfort themselves with the notion that the U.S. government will only torture “Islamo-fascists.” The administration’s Enemies List is far more expansive. The deal is not yet carved into the statute book, so…. On the same topic - The American Conservative posted online today my review of John Yoo’s new book, War by Other Means. Here are some outtakes of the review: George W. Bush has made absolutism respectable among American conservatives. And no one has done more pimping for president-as-Supreme-Leader than John Yoo, the former Justice Department official who helped create the “commander-in-chief override” doctrine, unleashing presidents from the confines of the law. At a time when Bush is pushing Congress to approve the use in military tribunals of confessions that resulted from torture, it is vital to understand the thinking of the Bush administration’s most visible advocate of “coercive interrogation.” Yoo’s new book, War by Other Means: An Insider’s Account of the War on Terror, reads like a slippery lawyer’s brief submitted to a dim judge who gets all his information from Fox News. Though Yoo’s misrepresentations and omissions should provoke outrage, his book will likely receive accolades from many conservative reviewers. This new volume compliments Yoo’s first book, The Powers of War and Peace, which revealed that the Founding Fathers intended to permit presidents to start wars on their own whims, regardless of what the Constitution says. Perhaps Yoo’s authoritarian tendencies resulted from his time at Harvard, where empowering an elite is always in fashion. Yoo paints every proposal for limiting the president’s power as a dangerous novelty. He is always trying to shift the burden of proof onto anyone who thinks the president should not be a czar. How could the people judge the policy when the Bush administration was suppressing almost all information about it? There were no independent probes into the torture scandal during 2004. All the investigators were under the thumb of the Pentagon. The investigations were designed to look only downward—with no authority to pursue wrongdoing to the highest branches of the Pentagon and the White House. The Bush team succeeded in delaying the vast majority of damning revelations until after he was re-elected. Presumably, the public can “approve” atrocities even when the government deceives them about the actual events. Yoo reasons like a devious personal-injury lawyer—yet it is the rights of the American people that are being run over. He is being feted by conservative foundations and think tanks, and often treated deferentially by liberals, for a theory of presidential power that would make Hobbes proud. Yoo believes Americans should presume that the government always has a good reason for violating the law, even when it deceives the citizens about the reasoning. Yoo’s doctrines are absolutely unfit for any system with a pretense of self-government.
……
While curtsying to the prevailing rhetoric on democracy, Yoo shows contempt for “government by consent.” He claims the 2004 election vindicated Bush’s torture policy: “Our nation had a presidential and congressional election after Abu Ghraib and the leaking of the [2002] memos. If the people had disagreed with administration policies, they could have made a change.”
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#1. To: hammerdown, Christine, Aristeides, Honway, All (#0)
What isn't being faced - as it's so horrible - is that the Bush Cabal doesn't give a rip about the American GI - if he can sacrifice the lives and limbs of the GI for heroin & oil; why can't the enemy just torture them? The only trick is to give them as few American prisoners, as possible - just as the case for casualties; make sure the other side fares far worse. It's that simple - it's all about POWER! Hitler sacrificed his Sturm Trupen, without a tear; Bush will do the same to the American GI. It's that damned simple! Anybody get it, yet??
i get it, sky.
Just as the promise of power brings the megalomanics, the promise of the power to torture other human beings brings the sadistic and sick out of the shadows to wreak suffering and humiliation. My God, it is insane that the government is even arguing and negotiating this inhumane practice. The war on terror is a deceitful concept and every act that springs from it is sinful. We as a nation are unwillingly or unwittingly represented by much worse than scoundrels and fools. Incarnate evil is easily recognizable by the critical mind even when covered by the thin veil of rightousness. The fact that so many do not see (or choose not to see) is the greatest indicatator of our moral decay. Our nation has fallen to greed, lust and arrogance. It has been rotting for decades. Now we must prepare ourselves for the price we must bear. The question, will that price be by our terms or theirs? The true nation within the USA, the honorable, proud and dignified, are angry and frustrated- but powerless and without unity. It's time my friends, time for the Twenty-Million Man march on DC! Surely there are that many willing to save our nation. Bring your own food and supplies... and your own voice.
yeah, SKY. I get it all too well.
The Geneva Conventions are "quaint" and "vague" to Alberto Gonzales. So let's put him in a uniform and send him over to the enemy for some first hand research into what the Geneva Conventions are all about.
"If there’s another 9/11 or a major war in the Middle-East involving a U.S. attack on Iran, I have no doubt that there will be, the day after or within days an equivalent of a Reichstag fire decree that will involve massive detentions in this country." - Daniel Ellsberg Author, Pentagon Papers a gang of liars, cheats and thieves doing business through the barrell of a gun...
Alberto 'Torquemada' Gonzales believes he is safe under the wing of the empire.
I'll second that!
"If there’s another 9/11 or a major war in the Middle-East involving a U.S. attack on Iran, I have no doubt that there will be, the day after or within days an equivalent of a Reichstag fire decree that will involve massive detentions in this country." - Daniel Ellsberg Author, Pentagon Papers i don't believe there are twenty million who are even aware we've a nation in need of saving and we would need at least that many.
I'm not sure whether or not there's 20 million that are aware ... I am fairly certain that there aren't 20,000,000 willing to make the necessary sacrifices to turn it around.
"eventus stultorum magister" Fools must be taught by experience
#2. To: SKYDRIFTER (#1)
#3. To: hammerdown (#0)
#4. To: SKYDRIFTER (#1)
#5. To: SKYDRIFTER (#1)
the Bush Cabal doesn't give a rip about the American GI
#6. To: lightmind (#3)
represented by much worse than scoundrels and fools.
omerta, if you will.
#7. To: robin (#5)
Aye, here's to changes in his lifetime.
#8. To: hammerdown (#7)
Alberto 'Torquemada' Gonzales believes he is safe under the wing of the empire. Aye, here's to changes in his lifetime.
#9. To: lightmind (#3)
The war on terror is a deceitful concept and every act that springs from it is sinful. We as a nation are unwillingly or unwittingly represented by much worse than scoundrels and fools. Incarnate evil is easily recognizable by the critical mind even when covered by the thin veil of rightousness. The fact that so many do not see (or choose not to see) is the greatest indicator of our moral decay.
#10. To: christine (#9)
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest