See other History Articles
Title: Book Review of "Bad Faith" by Carmen Callil
Source:
October issue of Atlantic Monthly
URL Source: [None]
Published: Sep 27, 2006
Author: Benjamin Schwarz
Post Date: 2006-09-27 21:13:57 by Diana
Keywords: France-bashing, Occupation, Anti-Semitism
Views: 153
Comments: 15
BAD FAITH by Carmen Callil (Knopf) In Germany and the countries it occupied, the Nazis had a knack for dredging up and empowering a host of weaselly charlatans, most of whom were inveterate anti-Semites and not a few of whom were degenerates, pimps, pornographers, thieves, or bully boys. But for their viciously effective patrons, most of this crew would have languished at the bottom of Europe's demimonde. But vaulted to positions of power (at least over the weak), they helped wreak terrible damage. Louis Darquier, who served from 1942 to 1944 as the commissioner for Jewish affairs in France's collaborating Vichy government, epitomized these effluvia of Nazi rule. A mountebank (he bestowed upon himself a noble title), an improvident sponger constantly on the run from his creditors, a wife-beating womanizer, and a braggart, the gallivanting, monoclied Darquier cut a ridiculous figure even among the rabble of 1930s French far-right anti-Semites. He had, however, some powerful benefactors even then, including the Nazis, who clandestinely helped fund his Jew-baiting propaganda before the war. After their conquest of France, they elevated him, though they found him an irksome blowhard, and eventually succeeded in foisting him onto the Vichy government, even though Marshal Petain, it's untratradionalist head of state, despised him. As a functionary Darquier was indolent and ineffective (and one of the very few who managed to put on weight during the war). He hated Jews, but essentially left the tedious work of administerding the Final Solution to France's highly competent civil servants - most infamously Rene Boussquet, Vichy's head of the police, who was later shielded from prosecution by his friend Francois Mitterrand, the French president. Still, Darquier spearheaded the hateful portrayal of Jews in the media and academe; he also looted Jewish property with abandon and sold certificates of Aryanization to the highest bidder. On his watch France's Jews were forced to wear the yellow star, and 12,884 of them - including 4,051 children - were hunted down in the notorious roundup of July 1942 and sent to internment camps, from which most were dispatched to their deaths at Auschwitz. After the war he escaped to Spain, where he lived unmolested and unrepentant (he famously told an interviewer that at Auschwitz the Germans had gassed only lice) until his death, in 1980. Callil, one of Britain's most lauded editors and publishers, came to her subject in a terrible fashion: as a young, unhappy woman, she was treated by a leading Jungian psychiatrist who, in 1970, killed herslef while Callil was under her care. That woman, Callil learned a few years later, was the daughter, whom Darqier and his alcoholic Australian wife had abandoned as an infant in 1930 during one of their low-life sprees, (really good journalism here, quite objective, NOT! - Diana) and who at adolescence had become acquainted with her father's repugnant past. Callil arrestingly weaves the sad story of Anne Darquier's grungy life, the chaos and plitical passions of the waning years of the Third Republic, and the sleazy intrigue and backbiting of the Vichy regime.
Poster Comment: The next book review after this one is about a book called, "A Mad, Bad & Dangerous People?" by Boyd Hilton (Oxford), which outlines the supposedly dispicable behavior of the British in the period 1783 - 1846. Here is a portion of it: "Industrialization blighted the country's North and Midlands; prompted the majority of it's population to shift from the country to putrid, overcrowded and unregulated towns and cities, with their dark, satanic mills; and caused a demographic calamity: a generation was literally stunted, and life expectancy in the industrializing areas dropped to levels unseen since the Black Death" This long article goes on portraying the English as little more than barbaric animals. There appears to be a trend lately to demonize all Europeans as being less than human and certainly antisemitic, even those countries who fought the Nazis and suffered and died under their rule. History is being twisted now to portray the situation as All Of Europe vs. The Jews. It's becoming painfully obvious that as time goes on, the seething resentment against ALL Europeans only grows; it's no longer only the Germans, it's now all of us. And who ever hears of Japan's role in WWII anymore?
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#1. To: aristeides, robin, Yertle Turtle, tom007, IndieTX, richard 9151, BTP Holdings, rowdee, All (#0)
I'm just sick of this crap.
There appears to be a trend lately to demonize all Europeans as being less than human and certainly antisemitic, even those countries who fought the Nazis and suffered and died under their rule. History is being twisted now to portray the situation as All Of Europe vs. The Jews. There must be a lot of unhappy people who like to digest this stuff.
"If there’s another 9/11 or a major war in the Middle-East involving a U.S. attack on Iran, I have no doubt that there will be, the day after or within days an equivalent of a Reichstag fire decree that will involve massive detentions in this country." - Daniel Ellsberg Author, Pentagon Papers That's the scary part. They read this stuff then get all worked up and fearful that nazis are going to come crawling out from under their beds to do them in. I have to wonder at times if the Jews realize what harm they cause when they put out such imflamatory articles! What double standards those radicals do have!!
Yup. And I wouldn't spend a dime on such garbage....it only encourgages them.
Seems a wee bit one sided, doughnut?
Blame Cornwall, it's all their fault! :)
The faster the Aryan Nation mob at Freedom4um are caged and chained, the better off we'll be. I’ll cheering when they are forced to behave. - Aaron
Fear is really popular right now. Without the Cold War it's a struggle. But they need something to take away our liberties and freedom. http://www.socialistworker.co.uk/article.php?article_id=9577 From ‘totalitarianism’ to ‘Islamofascism’
"If there’s another 9/11 or a major war in the Middle-East involving a U.S. attack on Iran, I have no doubt that there will be, the day after or within days an equivalent of a Reichstag fire decree that will involve massive detentions in this country." - Daniel Ellsberg Author, Pentagon Papers 9. To: Marguerite (#0) Goldi-Lox posted on 2006-09-27 12:57:58 ET (1 image) Reply Trace Hey, Diana: Oogaboogaboogaboo! And let that be a lesson to you.
The faster the Aryan Nation mob at Freedom4um are caged and chained, the better off we'll be. I’ll cheering when they are forced to behave. - Aaron
http://www.washington-report.org/backissues/0491/9104027.htm Check the date on this editorial.
"If there’s another 9/11 or a major war in the Middle-East involving a U.S. attack on Iran, I have no doubt that there will be, the day after or within days an equivalent of a Reichstag fire decree that will involve massive detentions in this country." - Daniel Ellsberg Author, Pentagon Papers A relative got the subscription for me. I must say I had never read it before, and I'm appalled at the overt hatred for European peoples in many of it's articles. It's arrogance and chutzpah at it's worst. I'm going to tell her how horrified I was at the articles, there was even another one before the one I typed in about how the French were horrible people during the occupation. I do notice the Irish seem exempt from all this, and it turns out Ireland never had much of a Jewish community or history, so there is no one there to wreck their "vengence" on. This is the type of magazine that people who think they are intellectuals brag about reading. It's nothing but poorly-written hateful exaggerations. If anything this garbage would make people dislike Jews. They are a tiny percentage of the population and they are insulting the (soon to not be) majority in the worst way possible.
The double-standard is outrageous. Makes me wonder if this sort of behavior was the cause for "anti-semitism" in Europe. Man those Japanese are lucky.
Hard to doubt it doncha think?
Among the major figures in the movement were former Trotskyites who studied in the '30s and '40s at the then "poor man's Harvard," the City College of New York, a center for socialist activism. They included Irving Kristol, who in the 1950s launched an anti-Soviet CIA front, the International Congress for Cultural Freedom; Norman Podhoretz, the editor of the American Jewish Committee's monthly magazine Commentary, which he turned into a major neoconservative outlet; Podhoretz's wife, Midge Decter, the chairperson of the now-defunct Committee on the Free World; sociologists Nathan Glazer and Daniel Bell; and Democratic Party pamphleteer Ben Wattenberg. And this was written in 1991. I think it's safe to say America does not rule America anymore. We are so screwed. Well soon it will be time to attack Iran and declare martial law here at home, and time to declare war on "anti- semitic" domestic terrorists who will most likely be put in slave labor camps by the millions just like in the good old days of the Soviet gulags.
He did not lie. But the author has a personal problem with this.
“The tendency of democracies is, in all things, to mediocrity, since the tastes, knowledge, and principles of the majority form the tribunal of appeal.” James Fenimore Cooper
#2. To: Jethro Tull, Dakmar (#1)
#3. To: Diana (#0)
This long article goes on portraying the English as little more than barbaric animals.
#4. To: robin (#3)
There must be a lot of unhappy people who like to digest this stuff.
#5. To: Diana (#1)
#6. To: Diana (#1)
#7. To: Diana (#2)
#8. To: Diana (#4)
#9. To: Diana (#4)
That's the scary part. They read this stuff then get all worked up and fearful that nazis are going to come crawling out from under their beds to do them in. I have to wonder at times if the Jews realize what harm they cause when they put out such imflamatory articles! What double standards those radicals do have!!
#10. To: Diana (#4)
#11. To: rowdee (#5)
Yup. And I wouldn't spend a dime on such garbage....it only encourgages them.
#12. To: tom007 (#6)
Seems a wee bit one sided, doughnut?
#13. To: Diana (#12)
Makes me wonder if this sort of behavior was the cause for "anti-semitism" in Europe.
#14. To: robin, Jethro Tull (#10)
Who are these neoconservatives, or the neocons," as both admirers and enemies refer to them? The neoconservative movement was founded in the 1960s by a group of New York-based intellectuals, mostly academics and journalists, many of whom were concerned about the "anti-Israel" drift they detected among the ranks of the New Left and Black leaders who were gaining increasing power in the Democratic Party.
#15. To: Diana (#0)
After the war he escaped to Spain, where he lived unmolested and unrepentant (he famously told an interviewer that at Auschwitz the Germans had gassed only lice) until his death, in 1980.
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest