See other Religion Articles
Title: Humans 'hardwired for religion'
Source:
Guardian
URL Source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/story/0,,1864748,00.html
Published: Apr 18, 2007
Author: James Randerson
Post Date: 2007-04-18 09:33:10 by Jethro Tull
Keywords: None
Views: 449
Comments: 14
Humans 'hardwired for religion' James Randerson Monday September 4, 2006 Guardian Unlimited The battle by scientists against "irrational" beliefs such as creationism is ultimately futile, a leading experimental psychologist said today. The work of Bruce Hood, a professor at Bristol University, suggests that magical and supernatural beliefs are hardwired into our brains from birth, and that religions are therefore tapping into a powerful psychological force. "I think it is pointless to think that we can get people to abandon their belief systems because they are operating at such a fundamental level," said Prof Hood. "No amount of rational evidence is going to be taken on board to get people to abandon those ideas."
Poster Comment: Hmmmmmmmm......
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#1. To: Jethro Tull (#0)
It's scriptural, we have a void. But for God, not religion. Certainly not Westboro Baptist Church. "Matthew Shepard has been in hell for 3110 days."
"The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes nor between parties either — but right through the human heart." — Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
I guess robin. I've never seen religious extremism cause more insanity and war than it is today. I have an article from the Jerusalem Post that claims the MRIs of Palestinian terrorist’s show malformations. Talk about racism. I’ll dig it up and post it here later. That said, overt thumpers are equally nuts IMO. I haven’t a clue how anyone can take Bible stories literally. I'm starting to believe religion either "takes" or is doesn't.
Bill Maher claims religions are the cause of all the world's problems. But I would be careful not to confuse religion with God. You could say that all organizations are the cause of all the world's problems and still be mostly accurate. At least the world's Merlins no longer sacrifice children and virgins to volcanoes to save and control a village. Oh nevermind, now the world's Merlins have human/drug trafficking and wars - to make money and control people. And we still need a good scare every few years, to remember who will save us.
"The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes nor between parties either — but right through the human heart." — Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
But I would be careful not to confuse religion with God. You could say that all organizations are the cause of all the world's problems and still be mostly accurate. Religion is the subversion of the spiritual and mystical to the very real power of those in control. Religion is about power on earth. It is about controlling the minds of the people, by shaping their reality. The Catholic Church, for example, was created to be the state religion, and was used to stamp out of Christianity the spiritual tenets in favor of dogma, learned and repeated without reference to its source or validity. The tale of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden is about religion denying to humans the path to spiritual enlightenment through ingesting the things that will give one the ability to discern good and evil, to have knowledge of the gods. It wasn't an apple they ate. It was a mushroom.
I think he ripped that off from George Carlin who has a funny Youtube rant on religion.
I'm not a Catholic, my husband is. As a Protestant I've always been rather leery of Catholicism, just because. "The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes nor between parties either — but right through the human heart." — Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
The Dalai Lama, the Pope - all part of the same problem from my perspective. Men who rule others through religion are not spiritual. They're men controlling other humans with brainwashing and shared delusions. IMO.
I like the Gnostic philosophy where is says "The Kingdom of Heaven is within you and all around you and not to be found in houses built by men". They also believed that you can recognize a true messenger by the fact that the messenger doesn't profit from the role of messenger. They use this to explain the crucifixion and note that it was necessary. Jesus was so popular at that time that he could not have avoided profiting from his role as a true messenger. These people were of course burned as heretics by the church.
Bunch of internet bums ... grand jury --- opium den ! ~ byeltsin
I agree. Christianity has been the whore of the powerful since about 325 CE, and it is primarily because it is about accumulating wealth and power. The Kingdom of heaven is at hand. It's here, all around us. We are in it.
I agree. As social animals, we imitate each other -- most learning is by imitation. Imitation minimizes knowledge costs, and when groups compete strong imitation maximizes response time and response effectiveness. An articulation of a religion is the cognitive ivy that adorns the real edifice, much more rationalization than reasoning. If religion has endured, it probably has survival value. In revolutions, the credo of the revolution, though perhaps not citing a god, performs the same psychological function as a religion. The article is correct to place quotation marks around "irrational." The process is arational. Ironically, rationalism itself is arational. "No amount of rational evidence is going to be taken on board to get people to abandon those ideas." True. Although it is not clear here, Hood may believe the problem is one of knowledge, which it is not. Consequences, not knowledge, change people. I have an article from the Jerusalem Post that claims the MRIs of Palestinian terrorist’s show malformations. It might be true, although calling them malformations may be just a bit of chauvinism.
It is far more likely that the buttocks became enlarged in response to sexual selection. This is what Darwin implied in the case of Hottentot women, in whom 'the posterior part of the body projects in a wonderful manner.' He mentions the admiration felt for this peculiarity by the males of their tribe. This should indeed not have surprised him; for he wrote his work on sexual selection at the time when bustles were in fashion in England... The admiration for this particular feature of feminine anatomy must, however, have been much more lasting among the Khoisanid males, for the remarkable results achieved suggest selection over a long period.
I can see how anyone might feel that way.
"The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes nor between parties either — but right through the human heart." — Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
I do not feel that holding political power can be reconciled with having spiritual awareness. The lines attributed to Jesus and others in this regard are very wise. Jesus, in the legend, refuses to follow the world of power and of glory. He refuses to sell out to his church's hierarchy or his political rulers. He warns those who follow him not to build a treasure on earth. Religion endures for many reasons. I think it is because we are pack animals, and we need some rituals in our lives to bond us. We also need to vehicle for certain thoughts and ideas. I also believe we believe in God because there is one, and we inherently knows this. We believe in spiritualism because it's real. Religion is Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, the yin and the yang of humans. We need the spiritual, but we tend to serve the ritual.
We are born with a strong sense of survival too, and wouldn't you know it, there's someone capitalizing on that too, along with every other instinct known to human beings.
"The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes nor between parties either — but right through the human heart." — Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
Yep. God did it.
It is not a Justice System. It is just a system.
#2. To: robin (#1)
#3. To: Jethro Tull (#2)
#4. To: robin (#3)
(Edited)
Bill Maher claims religions are the cause of all the world's problems.
#5. To: robin (#3)
Bill Maher claims religions are the cause of all the world's problems.
#6. To: Paul Revere (#4)
The Catholic Church, for example, was created to be the state religion, and was used to stamp out of Christianity the spiritual tenets in favor of dogma, learned and repeated without reference to its source or validity.
I've had opportunity to get better acquainted with it, and in it's favor I will say this:
It kept the Faith from being misinterpreted by a bunch of illiterates during the Dark and Middle Ages. You cannot blame the chaos that followed the fall of Rome on the Church. The Church, albeit imperfect, also brought with it education, universities, and high ideals.
The first fracture was with the Orthodox, and depending on your viewpoint, one broke away from the other. The next fracture was thanks to Luther, (sincere or sarcastic, depending on your viewpoint). After that it became a free-for-all, for anyone with a 4th grade education to mis-translate and misinterpret the Bible as he so chose. All these fractures have weakened Christendom, not strengthened it, which is not to say that it didn't needed a good purging or two or three, (e.g. the Borgias, Woolsey, the Inquisition, the torture for heresy, the witch trials, etc.).
#7. To: robin (#6)
#8. To: Paul Revere (#4)
Religion is the subversion of the spiritual and mystical to the very real power of those in control. Religion is about power on earth. It is about controlling the minds of the people, by shaping their reality.
#9. To: Minerva (#8)
(Edited)
I like the Gnostic philosophy where is says "The Kingdom of Heaven is within you and all around you and not to be found in houses built by men".
#10. To: Jethro Tull (#0)
#11. To: Paul Revere (#7)
#12. To: robin (#11)
(Edited)
#13. To: Paul Revere (#12)
#14. To: Jethro Tull (#0)
Humans 'hardwired for religion'
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest