[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help] 

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Cash Jordan: ICE Raids Taco Trucks... Deports 'Entire Parking Lot' of Migrants

Jaguar Went Woke & The Results Were Catastrophic

Trump Threatens To DEPORT ELON MUSK Over Big Beautiful Bill Feud, Elon NEVER Wanted EV Mandates

If Trump Cared About Israel, He would Stop the Genocide

Why do you think Henry Ford was such a hardcore Antisemite?

In Case you miss Bad Journalism

Bobby K Jr was Exiled For Saying This:

Quantum Meets AI: Morgan Stanley Maps Out Next Tech Frontier

670,000+ Swept Away as Dams Burst in Canton China, Triggering Deadly Flood!

Senate Version Of Trump Tax Bill Adds $3.3 Trillion To Deficit, $500BN More Than The House; Debt Ceiling Raised By $5 Trillion

Iran Disables GPS, Joins China’s Beidou — The End of U.S. Satellite Dominance?

Ukraine's Withdrawal From Anti-Personnel Landmine Treaty Could Haunt Generations

71 killed in Israeli attack on Iran's Evin Prison

Practice Small, Daily Acts Of Sabotage Against The Imperial Machine

"EVERYONE'S BEEN SHOT UP HERE": Arsonists Set Wildfire In Northern Idaho, Open Fire On Firefighters, Police In Ambush

Trump has Putin trapped, and the Kremlin knows it

Kamala's comeback bid sparks Democrat donor meltdown amid fears she'll sink party in California

Russia's New Grom-A1 100 KM Range Guided Bomb- 600 Kilo

UKRAINIAN CONSULATE IN ITALY CAUGHT TRAFFICKING WEAPONS, ORGANS & CHILDREN WITH THE MAFIA

Andrew Cuomo to stay on ballot for NYC mayor in November general election

The life of the half-immortal who advised CCP (End of CCP in 2026?)

Millions Flee China’s Top Cities

Violence begets violence: IDF troops beaten, choked, rammed by Jewish settlers in West Bank

Netanyahu Says It's Antisemitic For Israeli Soldiers To Describe Their Own Atrocities

China's Economy Spirals With No End In Sight, Says Kyle Bass

American Bread Cannot Be Sold in Most Countries

Woman Spent Her Life To Prove 796 Babies were buried under Catholic Home

Japan Got Rich Without Getting Fat

US Spent $495.3 million to fire 39 THAAD Missiles

Private Mail Back Online


Editorial
See other Editorial Articles

Title: The threat to al-Jazeera
Source: The Guardian
URL Source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/comment/story/0,,2103647,00.html
Published: Jun 14, 2007
Author: George Galloway
Post Date: 2007-06-14 22:55:01 by Eoghan
Ping List: *US is Proxy State For Israel*     Subscribe to *US is Proxy State For Israel*
Keywords: None
Views: 86
Comments: 4

It would be a disaster for the Middle East if the US neutered the region's most independent TV station

Since its launch just over a decade ago, the al-Jazeera satellite TV station has transformed the politics of the Middle East. For the first time, people in the region had access to a genuinely free and independent source of news and comment that was neither under the control of dictatorial regimes nor western states or corporations. Under its slogan of "The opinion ... and the other opinion", al-Jazeera gave an Arab world hungry for information and debate the means to talk to itself and shape its future. It spawned imitators across the region and has launched an English language station that is beginning to challenge the western monopoly of international news as a "voice of the global south". And the station also put Qatar, which sponsors it, on the political map and gave it unprecedented prestige throughout the Arab world and beyond.

But now that achievement is being put at risk. The evidence is clear that the US government is using its influence in Qatar to try to neuter the station's independence, bring it to heel and shift its coverage in a pro-western direction. If it succeeds, it would be a disaster for the Arab world and its chance to shape an independent and democratic future.

When al-Jazeera was launched in 1996, it was hailed by the US as a brave step towards liberalisation of the Middle Eastern media. But that all changed after September 2001 and the US invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq. The US administration could not tolerate a TV station that was popular and trusted in the Arab and Muslim world broadcasting about the reality of western and Israeli policies on the ground - and giving airtime to their enemies. Although US and Israeli viewpoints have always been given plenty of airtime, the freedom enjoyed by al-Jazeera's editorial staff has clearly been too liberal and democratic for the world's "leading democracy". Meanwhile, dictatorial regimes in the region pressed Washington to do something about this "turbulent priest" they believed was stirring their peoples against their despotic rule.

Initially, al-Jazeera had forced other channels in the Arab world to open up their coverage. But the new freedoms were not tolerated for long. And although the US government launched its own Arabic news channel al-Hurra, and Saudi Arabia al-Arabiya, neither succeeded in denting al-Jazeera's popularity.

But the station has had to pay a high price for its independence and professionalism. Its offices in Kabul and Baghdad were bombed by the US; its Baghdad correspondent Tariq Ayyub was killed; its Kabul correspondent Taysir Alluni was arrested in Spain and charged with terrorism; and its cameraman Sami Alhajj was kidnapped in Kabul and continues to be held in Guantánamo Bay. Most notoriously of all, George Bush even suggested to Tony Blair that they bomb al-Jazeera's Doha headquarters.

Now the US, which maintains a large military base in Qatar, has adopted a more subtle approach to breaking the Arabs' voice of independence and diversity. And the signs are that some elements in the Qatari government have yielded to the relentless US pressure. As one source close to al-Jazeera has put it: "You don't need to bomb a TV station to change its direction." A recent reshuffle has brought outspokenly pro-US directors on to the board, including a former Qatari ambassador to Washington. Another has boasted publicly that the tone and content of al-Jazeera's coverage is going to be changed. But these moves have already backfired and caused huge controversy not only in Qatar but throughout the Middle East, and there is every chance that what is in effect an attempted coup at the station will be reversed. It would be a huge loss for independence and freedom in the Arab world if it succeeded.

· George Galloway is Respect MP for Bethnal Green and Bow http://www.georgegalloway.com Subscribe to *US is Proxy State For Israel*

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Eoghan (#0)

But now that achievement is being put at risk. The evidence is clear that the US government is using its influence in Qatar to try to neuter the station's independence, bring it to heel and shift its coverage in a pro-western direction.

I read a few years ago that ownership of Al-Jazeera had sold 51% of it's ownership and would result in a more western-friendly media.

I've always suspected it played the role of bad cop, don't know for sure, but this article is interesting.

Diana  posted on  2007-06-14   23:43:59 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: Eoghan (#0)

A few years ago on their website they had a link to a very interesting site about Jewish women pioneers in the old American West, which was a fascinating website, but I found it odd that it was linked to Al-Jazeera.

Also their section on "conspiracy theories" reminded me too much of the BeAChooser mentality, it just seemed too westernized to be for real.

I haven't read it in awhile but that was my take on it back then.

Diana  posted on  2007-06-14   23:49:06 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: Eoghan (#0)

But these moves have already backfired and caused huge controversy not only in Qatar but throughout the Middle East, and there is every chance that what is in effect an attempted coup at the station will be reversed.

and here in america we just let it happen to our media. someone remind me why we're so superior???

kiki  posted on  2007-06-15   0:23:54 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#4. To: kiki, Diana, Eoghan (#3)

http://www.guardian.co.uk/comment/story/0,,2103647,00.html

Some of the comments at the end of the article are interesting...

----------------------------------------

JailingOpinionsCom

June 15, 2007 2:14 AM

Mr Galloway writes that the US government launched its own Arabic channel Al-Hurra in an attempt to compete with Al-Jazeera.

One should note that Congress has just last week withdrawn Al-Hurra's funding. Apparently the channel was not a sufficiently uncritical propaganda mouthpiece for Washington. In particular some congressmen objected that Al-Hurra had at least attempted to report objectively on the Tehran Holocaust Conference in December 2006.

Not content with moves to close down their own Arabic channel, Washington is now trying to twist arms in Qatar.

Meanwhile in France a retired professor, Robert Faurisson, is being prosecuted for remarks about historical issues broadcast on an Iranian channel.

Good to know that the Bush Administration and its trusted allies are making the world safe for democracy!

------------------------------------------------------

martinusher

June 15, 2007 2:52 AM

On a recent PBS "Frontline" program dealing with these Arab TV stations the head of al-Arabiya remarked of the visit of the Americans as "trying to sell an unsellable product". (The program was about the low key PR efforts in the area by the US Army (two people) and US State Department (one person).) Screwing up al-Jazeera will just cause another outlet to appear. As the US Army guys said, Al-Jazeera isn't the way it is because of some top-down editorial policy so much as its just responding to its customer base -- like, they said, Fox News Channel in the US.

Maybe the US needs to listen to its people on the ground. Having more than a handful of people in the State Department that are fluent in Arabic might also be useful as well. But I suppose they're so used to controlling the media here that they expect to do the same elsewhere.

"Guard against the impostures of pretended patriotism." ~George Washington

robin  posted on  2007-06-15   8:51:39 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help]