[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help] 

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

The Attack on the USS Liberty (June 8, 1967) - Speech by Survivor Phillip Tourney At the Revisionist History of War Conference (Video)

‘I Smell CIA/Deep State All Over This’ — RFK Jr. VP Nicole Shanahan Blasts Sanctuary Cities,

we see peaceful protests launching in Los Angeles” - Democrat Senator Cory Booke

We have no legal framework for designating domestic terror organizations

Los Angeles Braces For Another Day Of Chaos As Newsom Pits Marxist Color Revolution Against Trump Admin

Methylene Blue Benefits

Another Mossad War Crime

80 served arrest warrants at 'cartel afterparty' in South Carolina

When Ideas Become Too Dangerous To Platform

The silent bloodbath that's tearing through the middle-class

Kiev Postponed Exchange With Russia, Leaves Bodies Of 6,000 Slain Ukrainian Troops In Trucks

Iranian Intelligence Stole Trove Of Sensitive Israeli Nuclear Files

In the USA, the identity of Musk's abuser, who gave him a black eye, was revealed

Return of 6,000 Soldiers' Bodies Will Cost Ukraine Extra $2.1Bln

Palantir's Secret War: Inside the Plot to Cripple WikiLeaks

Digital Prison in the Making?

In France we're horrified by spending money on Ukraine

Russia has patented technology for launching drones from the space station

Kill ICE: Foreign Flags And Fires Sweep LA

6,000-year-old skeletons with never-before-seen DNA rewrites human history

First Close Look at China’s Ultra-Long Range Sixth Generation J-36Jet

I'm Caitlin Clark, and I refuse to return to the WNBA

Border Czar Tom Homan: “We Are Going to Bring National Guard in Tonight” to Los Angeles

These Are The U.S. States With The Most Drug Use

Chabria: ICE arrested a California union leader. Does Trump understand what that means?Anita Chabria

White House Staffer Responsible for ‘Fanning Flames’ Between Trump and Musk ID’d

Texas Yanks Major Perk From Illegal Aliens - After Pioneering It 24 Years Ago

Dozens detained during Los Angeles ICE raids

Russian army suffers massive losses as Kremlin feigns interest in peace talks — ISW

Russia’s Defense Collapse Exposed by Ukraine Strike


History
See other History Articles

Title: Back to Gettysburg
Source: t r u t h o u t
URL Source: http://www.truthout.org/docs_2005/063005Y.shtml
Published: Jul 1, 2005
Author: Lynn N. Hargis
Post Date: 2005-07-01 07:36:47 by Grumble Jones
Keywords: Gettysburg, Back
Views: 49
Comments: 5

Back to Gettysburg

The National Park Service does a pretty good job of preserving our country's historic places, but the historical interpretation sometimes seems molded to conform to current presidential policy. By William Marvel

Thirty-eight years ago the Class of 1967 filed out of the steaming gymnasium at Kennett High School in Conway, New Hampshire, 133 strong, and most of us carried fresh diplomas. During the graduation ceremony there had been a great deal of talk about heading down the highway of life and fulfilling our dreams, and I took it literally. I handed my gown to my mother, retrieved a knapsack from the family car, and struck off down Route 16 with my thumb out, headed for Gettysburg.

For most of my seventeen years the Civil War had formed the focal point of my interest in history, and in Civil War history all roads lead to Gettysburg. As it happened, that trip provided an education of its own, offering my first glimpses of city expressways, ghettoes, and suburban tract housing, all of which offended my rural sensibilities. West of Philadelphia, though, the turnpikes gave way to straight, narrow roads that glided over broad expanses of lush, rolling farmland. Quaint little brick villages punctuated that fertile landscape, where Amish and Mennonite residents had only begun to see their culture exploited for the profits of others.

Ignoring the tacky tourism that infected the town of Gettysburg, I went straight to the battlefield. It was the first time I ever wittingly stood where legendary events took place, and my sense of cosmic connection to that not-so-distant past seemed even stronger than it does now, after nearly four more decades of immersion in the sources of that era. I spent three days there, subsisting on peanut butter and crackers and sleeping surreptitiously on the battlefield at night.

The National Park Service interpretation at Gettysburg focused heavily on the theme of national reconciliation. The riots of 1968 and the antiwar movement had not yet riven the country into hostile camps, and it was still possible to argue that the mayhem of the 1860s had forged a better nation, especially if one overlooked the civil rights failures of Reconstruction and the corporate victory over Populist America. It all seemed logical to a boy from the sticks, and it took half a lifetime of concentrated study to revise that misconception.

Last week I returned to my childhood Mecca, foregoing the hitchhiking and outdoor sleeping in favor of a fuel-efficient van that doubles as a motel room. The final approach was not so pleasant: one generation later, the pleasant vistas of southeastern Pennsylvania are nearly gone. In their stead lie broad concrete and asphalt highways bordered by endless miles of new homes and commercial excreta. Where such blight has not intruded, endless orange road-construction signs promise to bring it.

The battlefield remains nearly the same, meanwhile, except for a maze of one-way roads and a more obvious police presence. Backpacks such as I carried in 1967 are now forbidden in the visitor center, and I suspect that I might be asked to explain myself if I were again spotted wandering the park for three successive days, but the greatest difference that I detected lay in the historical interpretation. I overheard a park ranger haranguing a crowd of visitors about the Gettysburg Address, and just as I began to notice how much he sounded like a preacher he reiterated the George W. Bush mantra for foreign intervention: the men who died at Gettysburg, said the ranger, were all fighting for "freedom and democracy," so the United States could spread those ideals around the world.

Perhaps he forgot that the Confederacy was based on the very opposite of freedom. Perhaps he never knew that a significant percentage of Union soldiers held no sympathy for emancipation, and resented being tricked into fighting a war for abolition. Perhaps useful rhetoric trumps inconvenient fact, especially in the case of government-owned history.

That Orwellian distortion notwithstanding, my latest hadj to Gettysburg remained a pleasant excursion into my own and my country’s past. The Park Service has made extensive efforts to restore the terrain to its 1863 appearance by clearing overgrown pastures, planting orchards, and maintaining fields. Deer, rabbits, and rare birds still thrive under federal protection. There are still kindred spirits walking the battlefield with whom a historical hobo can commune, including teenagers seeking the truth of that watershed epoch. The challenges they face today seem even more daunting than those of my youth, but if they search far enough beyond the myths of official dogma, they may actually find it.

Click for Full Text!

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: All (#0)

I just noticed I messed up several things.

The article is from "Intervention Magazine" and written by "William Marvel."

Here's the correct link

My apologies.

As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron. ....H.L. Mencken---

Grumble Jones  posted on  2005-07-01   7:41:44 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: Grumble Jones (#1)

that's OK. I think Gettysburgh was truly one of the greatest battles in all of history. How many died? About 60,000 total I think over 3-4 days mostly on one big field. That field was sloped to the east I believe with the northern troops in the north, the southern troops in the south. There was a creek on the east edge of that field. The blood literally trickled into it. The southern troops had to drink from that creek. They drank pink water history records, and some of them puked from it.

On Pickett's charge they lost 15,000 men I believe. And of course, the tide of the war turned at this battle.

Red Jones  posted on  2005-07-01   10:31:29 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: Red Jones (#2)

that's OK. I think Gettysburgh was truly one of the greatest battles in all of history. How many died? About 60,000 total I think over 3-4 days mostly on one big field. That field was sloped to the east I believe with the northern troops in the north, the southern troops in the south. There was a creek on the east edge of that field. The blood literally trickled into it. The southern troops had to drink from that creek. They drank pink water history records, and some of them puked from it.

On Pickett's charge they lost 15,000 men I believe. And of course, the tide of the war turned at this battle.

About 12,000 KIA.

About 56,000 total killed, wounded and missing on July 1,2 and 3.

I think you're referring to the 1 mile wide field which is between Cemetary Ridge (union) and Seminary Ridge (South) which was the site of Pickett's charge on the 3rd day. The South came from the west to the East. Approx 12,000 Confederate troops were involved with 7,000 Southern casualities. You may also mean the Wheatfield which isn't very large. The Wheatfield had a lot of action on the 2nd when Sickles defied orders and left his position on Cemetary Ridge.

Plum Run is the creek you're mentioning which runs through the "Valley of Death" which is S.E. of Little Round Top. The stories about it are true.

As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron. ....H.L. Mencken---

Grumble Jones  posted on  2005-07-01   16:47:58 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#4. To: Grumble Jones (#3)

Thanks for posting. I changed my tagline earlier today in remembrance.

Pickett was off like a shot and called out to his men: "Up, men, and to your posts! Don't forget today that you are from Old Virginia!" July 3, 1863.

robin  posted on  2005-07-01   16:50:48 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#5. To: robin (#4)

Something little known happened on the 2nd day that possibly changed the outcome.

Lee wanted Longstreet to attack up the Emmitsburg road. Longstreet has always gotten the blame for not getting his battle lines formed soon enough. There was a reason for that. In the early morning of July 2nd,Longstreet wanted to take his troops through the town first to get them into position. Lee insisted the supply train go first which caused a huge delay.

If not for that,Longstreet could have gotten his attack off before Sickles had a chance to move his troops in Longstreet's way and ruin his plans. Sickles blunder may have actually saved the North from being defeated that day.

As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron. ....H.L. Mencken---

Grumble Jones  posted on  2005-07-01   17:43:24 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help]