[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help] 

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

The Attack on the USS Liberty (June 8, 1967) - Speech by Survivor Phillip Tourney At the Revisionist History of War Conference (Video)

‘I Smell CIA/Deep State All Over This’ — RFK Jr. VP Nicole Shanahan Blasts Sanctuary Cities,

we see peaceful protests launching in Los Angeles” - Democrat Senator Cory Booke

We have no legal framework for designating domestic terror organizations

Los Angeles Braces For Another Day Of Chaos As Newsom Pits Marxist Color Revolution Against Trump Admin

Methylene Blue Benefits

Another Mossad War Crime

80 served arrest warrants at 'cartel afterparty' in South Carolina

When Ideas Become Too Dangerous To Platform

The silent bloodbath that's tearing through the middle-class

Kiev Postponed Exchange With Russia, Leaves Bodies Of 6,000 Slain Ukrainian Troops In Trucks

Iranian Intelligence Stole Trove Of Sensitive Israeli Nuclear Files

In the USA, the identity of Musk's abuser, who gave him a black eye, was revealed

Return of 6,000 Soldiers' Bodies Will Cost Ukraine Extra $2.1Bln

Palantir's Secret War: Inside the Plot to Cripple WikiLeaks

Digital Prison in the Making?

In France we're horrified by spending money on Ukraine

Russia has patented technology for launching drones from the space station

Kill ICE: Foreign Flags And Fires Sweep LA

6,000-year-old skeletons with never-before-seen DNA rewrites human history

First Close Look at China’s Ultra-Long Range Sixth Generation J-36Jet

I'm Caitlin Clark, and I refuse to return to the WNBA

Border Czar Tom Homan: “We Are Going to Bring National Guard in Tonight” to Los Angeles

These Are The U.S. States With The Most Drug Use

Chabria: ICE arrested a California union leader. Does Trump understand what that means?Anita Chabria

White House Staffer Responsible for ‘Fanning Flames’ Between Trump and Musk ID’d

Texas Yanks Major Perk From Illegal Aliens - After Pioneering It 24 Years Ago

Dozens detained during Los Angeles ICE raids

Russian army suffers massive losses as Kremlin feigns interest in peace talks — ISW

Russia’s Defense Collapse Exposed by Ukraine Strike


Dead Constitution
See other Dead Constitution Articles

Title: Quiz Time: (Hypothetical Question)
Source: [None]
URL Source: [None]
Published: Apr 17, 2008
Author: Neil McIver
Post Date: 2008-04-17 21:33:40 by Pinguinite
Keywords: None
Views: 2736
Comments: 73

Okay, 4umers, quiz time.

I've got a hypothetical question for you. Suppose you were in a funny situation where you had the opportunity to reconstitute the 2nd Amendment, doing away with all 20,000 or so gun laws. The power was in your hands to make it so.

But there's one catch. In order to make this wish come true, you first had to pick up a gun, put it to the head of an innocent 7 year old girl, and pull the trigger, blowing her brains out. With that task completed, the 2nd Amendment would be restored all across America.

Would you do it? If your answer is "yes" then this quiz is over for you. You may resume your perusing of 4um and disregard the rest of the test.

If your answer is no, then we'll expand our hypothetical scenario.

After you refuse to kill this girl, someone else steps up and says "I am also interested in restoring the 2nd Amendment, and I am willing to do what must be done for you. If I am elected president, I will shoot this girl and then the 2nd Amendment will be restored".

Question: Do you vote for this man or not?

It would seem that some people here on 4um would happily endorse the death of this girl one way or another in order to restore 2nd Amendment rights. I am not one of those people, which is why a couple days ago I wrote the following:

For us to try to safeguard our 2nd Amendment rights at the expense of lives of innocents worldwide doesn't fly in my book.

This apparently earned me the label of "gun grabber" in the minds of a few here.

I honestly don't know why. Honestly. Does the phrase "expense of lives of innocents" mean something other than "murder" to people here?

I really feel like I've entered the twilight zone. You know, where the whole world changes but you don't. In this case, it's like learning suddenly that a bunch of 4umers would indeed blow the brains of of a little girl if it helped to secure some of their own "liberties". I am really amazed that a number of people here take exception to my statement.

As this hypothetical scenario applies to the real world, if there was a pres candidate promising to work to fully restore the 2nd Amendment in the USA while simultaneously promising to bomb the rest of the world into oblivion, I could not in good conscious vote for him. Call me crazy or call me a gun grabber if you want, but if not being willing to kill this way makes me a gun grabber, then I hope I'm a gun grabber for life. But I would not, could not support such a "pro 2nd Amendment" candidate. Never.

If I am truly in the minority on this point on 4um, then perhaps I should resign my account and leave you all.

Thank you for reading.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

Begin Trace Mode for Comment # 26.

#1. To: Pinguinite (#0)

I could not hurt her, and I would try to protect the little girl, who might someday grow up to write or say something that would move millions to support second amendment freedoms knowing that her life had been spared.

I do think this is a false dilemma. I saw the thread where you and another poster were having a discussion about this in a different form (related to Obama).

I don't believe he is what he seems, and even if he is, he would not be permitted to move to protect innocent young lives at the expense of the globalists' agenda.

I respect your concern and your desire to see the world improved by reforming American foreign policy. The down side of this false dilemma is that McCain and Rodham do not have better stances on gun control than Obama.

This is a false dilemma in both directions.

buckeye  posted on  2008-04-17   21:40:19 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#17. To: buckeye (#1)

I do think this is a false dilemma. I saw the thread where you and another poster were having a discussion about this in a different form (related to Obama).

Thanks for replying.

You're right that Obama may very well keep the occupation going another 4 years. Politicians being what they are, he could do anything. But my statement was generic and not directed toward any particular candidate. Certainly my beatings the past 2 days were for being a gun grabber, not an Obama supporter.

Pinguinite  posted on  2008-04-17   22:18:15 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#20. To: Pinguinite (#17)

Certainly my beatings the past 2 days were for being a gun grabber, not an Obama supporter.

I might have misunderstood, but I figured this was about support for any candidate who was in favor of draconian gun control, which they each are. I don't figure a vote for any one of them or another will make a difference.

buckeye  posted on  2008-04-17   22:24:59 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#26. To: buckeye (#20)

I might have misunderstood, but I figured this was about support for any candidate who was in favor of draconian gun control,

My original statement, which was really off the cuff (I didn't even make a showcase of it -- it was the second sentence in the second paragraph of a 3 paragraph post) was really comparing the right of one party to live vs the right of a second party to have a gun, as per the hypothetical.

Pinguinite  posted on  2008-04-17   22:59:06 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


Replies to Comment # 26.

#28. To: Pinguinite (#26)

We're all worried about gun control, but meanwhile there's a push on for "Net Neutrality" again. We need the first amendment protected more than anything else. You don't have any hypothetical dilemmas to offer about that problem, do you?

buckeye  posted on  2008-04-17 23:06:22 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


End Trace Mode for Comment # 26.

TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Sign-in]  [Mail]  [Setup]  [Help]