See other (s)Elections Articles
Title: Obama Campaign Pushing Back Hard Against Corsi Smears
Source:
[None]
URL Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/ ... paign-punches-ba_n_119031.html
Published: Aug 15, 2008
Author: Seth Walls
Post Date: 2008-08-15 12:06:06 by christine
Keywords: None
Views: 157
Comments: 6
As promised, Barack Obama's campaign is hitting back hard against smear author Jerome Corsi's New York Times best-selling book The Obama Nation. In an exhaustive 41-page PDF document entitled Unfit for Publication -- a riff on Corsi's 2004 Unfit for Command, which targeted John Kerry -- the campaign documents every false claim they have been able to find in Corsi's current tome. No matter how small the error, including the year the Obamas married, the campaign has taken time to correct the record. Clearly, the cumulative effect is meant as a kind of rhetorical "shock and awe" campaign against Corsi, who is described in the prelude of Unfit for Publication as "a discredited, fringe bigot" who "believes that President Bush is trying to merge the United states with Mexico and Canada," in addition to holding other conspiracy theories. "Corsi has penned a litany of bigoted, hateful comments-- crossing the line so thoroughly that even the right-wing operatives behind Swift Boat Veterans for Truth disavowed him. This is a man who smears the Catholic Church, calls the Pope 'senile,' and regularly demeans public servants in vile sexual and racial terms," the document reads. "In short, his record of attacks is disgusting and false, and so is this book." And then comes the table of contents. Overall, the response memo was produced in a comprehensively media-savvy style meant to inspire more critical coverage of Corsi's book, and perhaps a few giggles at the author's expense, as well. The document's satirical cover carries a seal next to Corsi' picture that reads: "Brought To You By Bush/Cheney Attack Machine," and a quote from Joe Klein's Time.com blog post calling The Obama Nation "poisonous crap." As for the content of the Obama camp's rebuttals, they also appear comprehensive. After a short section excerpting Corsi's bad reviews thus far, the bulk of the document is a section dedicated to the book's falsehoods. And the inaccuracies in Corsi's book appear vast indeed, from the small and quotidian to the large and substantive. Apparently, Corsi got next to everything wrong about Obama's own books, Dreams from My Father and The Audacity of Hope. Whereas Obama Nation claims that "Nowhere in the autobiography does Obama disclose that his wife-to-be accompanied him to Africa on the 1992 trip," the Obama response lays out the actual passage in full: "After our engagement, I took Michelle to Kenya to meet the other half of my family. She was an immediate success there as well, in part because the number of Luo words in her vocabulary very soon surpassed mine. We had a fine time in Alego, helping Auma on a film project of hers, listening to more of Granny's stories, meeting relatives I'd missed the first time around." Elsewhere in Corsi's book, he writes that "Obama failed to discuss his father's alcoholism and polygamy in his autobiography," despite the passage from Obama's book that reads: "He would come home very late, drunk, and I could hear him shouting at Ruth, telling her to cook him food. ... Then he would stagger in drunk and come into my room and wake me because he wanted company or something to eat. He would talk about how unhappy he was and how he had been betrayed." For what it's worth, Corsi also falsely claims that Obama did not dedicate Dreams to his family, despite the dedication page that reads: "It is to my family, though -- my mother, my grandparents, my siblings, stretched across oceans and continents -- that I owe the deepest gratitude and to whom I dedicated this book. Without their constant love and support, without their willingness to let me sing their song and their toleration of the occasional wrong note, I could never have hoped to finish. If nothing else, I hope that the love and respect I feel for them shines through on every page." As for politics, Corsi repeatedly distorts Obama's actions and positions -- at one point accusing him of meddling in Kenyan politics after U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice asked him to tape a radio message for broadcast there. Corsi's rhetorical suggestion that Obama's stance on Israel is "merely a matter of political convenience" meets with a page-and-a-half rebuttal in "Unfit for Publication," with statements from Obama going back to 2000. Corsi's suggestion that Obama approved of Louis Farrakhan's views is also rebutted with a 1995 article penned by Obama. After 29 pages of this, the Obama campaign's response document turns again to the subject of Corsi and his "widely discredited beliefs." At one point, the document quotes a writer for the conservative website Human Events who said Corsi is not "any more worthy of being taken seriously than those who think Jews rule the world or the 'Truthers' who think President Bush is responsible for 9/11." In providing all this oppo research to the media so quickly after the book's publication, the Obama campaign is clearly trying to avoid John Kerry's fate in 2004, when some media outlets reported in neutral fashion about the claims in Corsi's Unfit for Command for far too long. This time, at least, the Democrat can't be accused of holding back in the face of false attacks.
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#1. To: christine (#0)
Cheapest neck brace I can find is $7.50.
Negro parents, as a rule, seem disposed not only to give larger liberty to their children than they ought, but they give absolute license in too many instances. In illustration of this fact, in cities particularly, children are allowed to go from their homes in the night-time and wander the streets amid their baleful associations until nine, ten, eleven o'clock and longer. And when they return home they do so unattended... This condition does not obtain alone among children of ignorant and poor parentage, but absence of good manners is also often found among children and youths who have had fair common and high school advantages. -- John Henry Smyth, 1902
This paragraph is the crux of the matter and reveals the writer's mindset - and who pulls his string - strongly pro-government pro-NWO. This is a hit piece against Corsi. Whatever errors he might have made this litany relies upon points that are minor significances. Corsi missing a paragraph in his research while not good does not vitiate his points on Oh'Bummer which in the main would appear valid since the rebuttal does not address any major points. The inclusion of the line, "..."not "any more worthy of being taken seriously than those who think Jews rule the world or the 'Truthers' who think President Bush is responsible for 9/11.", is instructive by the technique used in associating Corsi with views that the author regards as discredited and discreditable. Without going off on a tangent to show that such views are not without support or substantiation, in part because the audience on this web site already knows that, but the point here is the attempt to damn by association. That shows also that the author has no points of any significance with which to attack Corsi. Thus by extension we can also conclude that much of what Corsi wrote is well documented and that the Oh'Bummerphiles, and the media disinfo people, cannot refute them. Yes his errors are sloppy scholarship, but they do not disprove Corsi's main thesis that Oh'Bummer is an empty suit who stands for whatever he thinks people will fall for as well as the history of his wife as a Black bigot. That most likely is the real target - to prevent people from observing the obvious - that Oh'Bummer's wife is a hate filled individual and by connection what does that say about Oh'Bummer's real views which are not in the public sphere. No, I think the furor says that Corsi hit paydirt and the full court press is now on to discredit the salvo.
"The difference between an honorable man and a moral man is that an honorable man regrets a discreditable act even when it has worked and he is in no danger of being caught." ~ H. L. Mencken
No doubt Corsi's criticism of Obama are valid but it is unfortunate that it is Corsi who brings the criticisms to the light of day and not some other author, who has a less "target rich" past. See my #4 post in the following thread:
i can't give Corsi a pass on that. if you're going to write a book like this, you better be damn sure you've not included information that is so easily disproved assuming that is the case. i've not read his book nor have i read either of Obama's. i understand Corsi has over 700 footnotes in his tome. as for the attacks on Corsi, i'm in agreement with OI in that i believe anyone who writes a book such as this becomes a target in reverse. the old 'shoot the messenger'. a tactic used by both sides--the leftwing and the rightwing.
Do You Know What Freedom Really Means? Freedom4um.com
I'm still waiting for the campaign to correct Hussein Obama's quotation of America having 57 states. I'm also waiting for campaign photo's of Hussein Obama's WHITE family members to be widely circulated instead of acting like they don't even exist. Hussein Obama: you are a FRAUDULENT BASTARD.
He wants to keep the black vote locked up so that won't happen. Most American blacks don't even know Obama is mixed becasue many American blacks are mixed themselves and don't even know it.
God is always good!
At one point, the document quotes a writer for the conservative website Human Events who said Corsi is not "any more worthy of being taken seriously than those who think Jews rule the world or the 'Truthers' who think President Bush is responsible for 9/11."
#2. To: christine, TwentyTwelve, Wudidiz, Ferret Mike, robin, aristeides, Peppa, tom007, CadetD, Diana, lodwick, Burkeman1, Brian S, all (#0)
After 29 pages of this, the Obama campaign's response document turns again to the subject of Corsi and his "widely discredited beliefs." At one point, the document quotes a writer for the conservative website Human Events who said Corsi is not "any more worthy of being taken seriously than those who think Jews rule the world or the 'Truthers' who think President Bush is responsible for 9/11."
#3. To: Original_Intent, christine, TwentyTwelve, Wudidiz, Ferret Mike, robin, aristeides, Peppa, tom007, CadetD, Diana, lodwick, Burkeman1, Brian S, all (#2)
No, I think the furor says that Corsi hit paydirt and the full court press is now on to discredit the salvo.
#4. To: Original_Intent, scrapper2 (#2)
Yes his errors are sloppy scholarship,
#5. To: christine (#0)
“The best and first guarantor of our neutrality and our independent existence is the defensive will of the people…and the proverbial marksmanship of the Swiss shooter. Each soldier a good marksman! Each shot a hit!” Schweizerische Schutzenseitunt (Swiss Shooting Federation) April, 1941
#6. To: X-15 (#5)
I'm also waiting for campaign photo's of Hussein Obama's WHITE family members to be widely circulated instead of acting like they don't even exist.
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest