The death of George Floyd reminds us how easy it is to kill and why law enforcement and the armed forces must remain separate.
The death of George Floyd in Minneapolis on Monday demonstrates how easy it is to end a life. Floyd wasnt shot with a firearm, as was Philando Castile during a traffic stop four years ago. He wasnt even tossed in the back of a police van, as was Freddie Gray before that. The weapon was a simple knee to the neck. The video of his arrest is chilling precisely because its casual, quotidian almost, just another day on the job for his badge-bearing assailants, a stark contrast to the victim gasping on the ground.
Floyds killing has touched off yet another of that most depressing of sequences: a video emerges showing a black man being brutalized by police; his community protests peacefully; those demonstrations are hijacked by rioters and professional anarchists; Molotov cocktails fly; flames erupt. An act of harm by the authorities is followed by a city-wide act of self-harm.
Afterwards the question is always: now what do we do? And certainly there are plenty of good policy reforms that can help restore trust between law enforcement and local communities. Donald Trump in 2018 signed into law the First Step Act, which ordered changes to the prison and sentencing systems. In the meantime, though, how about we start with some low-hanging fruit? How about we stop arming police departments with military-grade equipment?
Philip V. McHarris writes at the Washington Post:
Such protests have become common in a country where more than 1,000 people annually are killed by police, with black people three times as likely as whites to be the victims. Also common is what happened soon after demonstrators gathered to protest Floyds death: Police in riot gear shot tear gas canisters into the crowds and fired stun grenades and nonlethal projectiles at demonstrators, injuring many. It was stunningly easy to point to the same departments gentle treatment weeks ago against white anti-lockdown protesters while those protesting against police violence were met with militarized violence.
But this too should not surprise us. Police departments have come to resemble military units, contributing to deadly violence disproportionately against black Americans. While many policies related to policing and mass incarceration happen at the local level, the militarization of police has been promulgated by federal policies.
At issue is the Pentagons so-called 1033 program, which allows police to obtain military surplus equipment from the Defense Department. Among the gear thats been transferred over the years are grenade launchers, armored troop carriers, M16 rifles, and helicopters. And while its difficult to find data on the Minneapolis PD specifically, the Star Tribune reported six years ago that police in Minnesota had received about $25 million in defense hardware. (Its worth pointing out that not all of the military-grade equipment used by law enforcement comes from the Pentagonsome of it is privately purchased by the departments themselves.)
The result has been the creeping militarization of our police. This trend made national headlines in 2014 after cops in Ferguson, Missouri, used armored vehicles to suppress riots sparked by the death of Michael Brown. That next year, President Obama signed an executive order that stopped the Pentagon from transferring some hardware to police departments. This forced Ferguson to send back, among other things, two Humvee armored trucks.
Alas, President Trump reversed Obamas order in 2017, allowing Pentagon equipment to proliferate once again. So now we have another episode of police brutality, this one courtesy of a simple knee to the neck. But that only raises the question: if police are human like the rest of us, and if all it takes for them to kill is a little bodily force, shouldnt we refrain from upping the ante with, say, grenades? Shouldnt the balance between guardian and ward be evener than that, lest it instead become a balance between bully and victim? Isnt an armored truck a barrier to the kind of involved community policing we should be encouraging? And can anyone seriously say that the presence of military equipment in Ferguson all those years ago did more good than harm?
The looting and burning that took place in Minneapolis last night was senseless, no question. But the solution is not to turn the police into an occupying army. Such powers of last resort force are better left to an impermanent force like the National Guard, which Minneapoliss mayor said he was calling in.
After Reconstruction, Congress passed the Posse Comitatus Act, which provided that it shall not be lawful to employ any part of the Army of the United States, as a posse comitatus, or otherwise, for the purpose of executing the laws, except in such cases and under such circumstances as such employment of said force may be expressly authorized by the Constitution or by act of Congress. That law has plenty of loopholes and blurs. It doesnt cover the Navy or Marines (though other statutes do); it also doesnt restrain the lawful deployment of the National Guard. Yet its spirit is worth preserving. The military and the police should be kept distinct, one for overseas combat, the other for domestic enforcement. To give the latter the destructive potential of the former is to vault over a very important line.
#1: StraitGate To: Ada (#0)
"We"? I wasn't with Matt when he did that, and I'll bet few of his readers were either.
Why do people who oppose the wicked U.S. government's actions often use "we" when referring to that government's latest outrage? If the writer wants to share the blame, fine, but such pieces always imply that the reader is part of the writer's "we" and thus also culpable.
One morning a few years ago my son-in-law told me "Now we're bombing Libya!" I said I didn't remember bombing Libya -- I was home last night.
Anybody who suffers from the delusion that the U.S. government is "we" should visit the nearest federal building and tell the marshals you need to borrow an SUV from "our" motor pool. Let me know how we did, huh?
StraitGate posted on 2020-05-30 09:39:55 Reply Private Reply
#2: AllTheKings'HorsesWontDoIt To: Ada (#0)
.
Partnering with Law Enforcement | Anti-Defamation League
https://www.adl.org/.../signature-programs/partnering-with-law- enforcement
Partnering with Law Enforcement. More law enforcement turn to ADL than to any other non-governmental organization for training, information and resourcesto combat extremism, terrorism and hate crimes. ADL works with every major federal, state and local law enforcement agency, from the Federal Bureau of Investigation to major city police departments, state police, highway patrol and
AllTheKings'HorsesWontDoIt posted on 2020-05-30 21:13:23 Reply Private Reply
#3: NeoconsNailed To: StraitGate (#1)
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-05-30 21:24:04 Reply Private Reply
#4: NeoconsNailed To: Ada, BTP Holdings, Bill D Berger, randge (#0)
Blip on the screen with Daily Caller video:
https://www.theorganicprepper.com/minneapolis-armed-citizens-deter/
As Minneapolis Burns, Armed Citizens Deter Rioters and Looters Without Firing a Shot
https://www.freedomsphoenix.com/News/283735-2020-05-29-as- minneapolis-burns-armed-citizens-deter-rioters-and-looters- without.htm
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-05-30 21:29:21 Reply Private Reply
#5: StraitGate To: NeoconsNailed (#3)
Nobody who practices or mindlessly tolerates that can ever know the peace and satisfaction that comes from being mentally liberated and separated from the psychopaths in government.
If I can help even one person here into that light my work here will not have been in vain.
StraitGate posted on 2020-05-30 22:04:54 Reply Private Reply
#6: NeoconsNailed To: StraitGate (#5)
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-05-30 22:40:41 Reply Private Reply
#7: BTP Holdings To: NeoconsNailed (#4)
When I lived in NW suburban Chicago, the Bearded Bandit shot a Palatine cop with an Australian Semi-Auto pistol (.223).
They showed a picture in the paper of a Palatine cop carrying an H&K MP-5 (9mm) looking for the guy. I can guarantee it was selective fire.
That was a military toy.
After they caught him, they put him in the federal lock up in the Dirksen Building in downtown Chicago.
A guy I worked with, his Dad was a Deputy U.S. Marshal. He killed the bearded bandit on the parking ramp of he Dirksen building when he was trying to escape. :-O
BTP Holdings posted on 2020-05-30 22:50:47 Reply Private Reply
#8: X-15 To: Ada (#0)
X-15 posted on 2020-05-31 00:45:09 Reply Private Reply
#9: Ada To: X-15 (#8)
Could it be that they have been given orders to stand down?
Ada posted on 2020-05-31 07:11:48 Reply Private Reply
#10: NeoconsNailed To: BTP Holdings (#7)
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-05-31 07:25:43 Reply Private Reply
#11: BTP Holdings To: NeoconsNailed (#10)
That was Jeffery Erickson in Chicago area. The way I remember it, he washed out as a Rolling Meadows cop. He then turned to a life of crime. It ended badly for him and his wife. ;)
www.chicagotribune.com/ne...-21-9203050628-story.html
BTP Holdings posted on 2020-05-31 07:45:24 Reply Private Reply
#12: NeoconsNailed To: BTP Holdings (#11)
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-06-01 00:16:00 Reply Private Reply
#13: Bill D Berger To: NeoconsNailed (#4)
"Giving government money and power is like giving car keys and whiskey to a teenage boy" - P.J. O'Rourke
He was a writer for the National Lampoon, became a conservative pundit.
Bill D Berger posted on 2020-06-01 00:46:26 Reply Private Reply
#14: Lod To: Bill D Berger, all (#13)
Lod posted on 2020-06-01 06:48:42 Reply Private Reply
#15: BTP Holdings To: NeoconsNailed (#12)
I don't know.
But my ex partner in Chicago was robbing people for money and drugs.
One time one of the guys that was with him said his name. But the guy they robbed misunderstood and they were looking for someone else.
I saw his cousin at a Bears game and I asked if he had seen him.
He said, "Man, he wigged out and moved to Texas."
If the guy they had robbed had caught up with him he would have been six feet under.
He wasn't robbing nickels and dimes. It was tens of thousands of dollars. :-/
BTP Holdings posted on 2020-06-01 07:57:39 Reply Private Reply
#16: NeoconsNailed To: Bill D Berger (#13)
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-06-01 10:40:11 Reply Private Reply