200 Proofs Earth is Not a Spinning Ball
| Source: | https://youtu.be/-Ax_YpQsy88 |
| Published: | Dec 29, 2019 |
| Author: | Eric Dubay |
| Post Date: | 2019-12-29 19:57:38 by wudidiz |
| Views: | 44960 |
| Source: | https://youtu.be/-Ax_YpQsy88 |
| Published: | Dec 29, 2019 |
| Author: | Eric Dubay |
| Post Date: | 2019-12-29 19:57:38 by wudidiz |
| Views: | 44960 |
#204: Liberator To: NeoconsNailed, wudidiz, Earth (#175)
Tossing "massive rocks at Goliath" (and exposing Goliath's deception of our world) is one way to look at it.
With respect to fighting the 666 Beast System, yes TRUTH is indeed the antidote.
It is up to the individual whether they voluntarily take the Red Pill or Blue Pill, right? ('The Matrix' flick was indeed more "Predictive Programming', another case of giving away an open secret of the PTB)
Moreover, as Jesus said:
"And do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. But rather fear Him who is able to destroy both soul and body in hell." ~ Matthew 10:28 KJV
This is deadly serious business. The rocket godlets have made almost literal mountains of money giving us mere movies, and cheap stupid ones at that!
HA! You've touched on two great observations above....
a) The entire failed Mission by NASA is a modern day attempt by man to build *their* version of The Tower of Babel in order to "reach the Heavens" where God resides. We know what God did to it and the Babylonians.
b) The combined NASA/Hollywood productions have been about programming the Sheeple and creating illusions of "Space Travel" and "interstellar" infinite Universe.
Despite $52 MIL per day, their "Moon" productions since 1969-1972 have been proven cheap, unconvincing to many, and fraudulent hoaxes and theater when scrutinized. Epic examples of this are plastered all over YouTube.
Once again it's parallel to the wars, to which it's obviously related: trillions disappear with absolutely no benefit to the citizenry. The ego trip this scam gives the govt and military has to be a huge factor in cowing the ppl into submission and getting away with ever more mayhem.
+1000.
9/10: Sec Def Rumsfeld presser: "The Pentagram has lost $2.3 Tril."
9/11: "Nevermind."
(POOF!! The entire accounting dept at the Pentagram was atomized by a phantom "passenger jet.")
Yes, regarding another unmistakable point of yours; power is always an ego trip. Gummint has a blank check to buy whomever they want (MSM, Scientists, Educators, Entertainers, "Astroturfers") to DO whatever they want (incl causing social upheavals & launching expensive, endless war based on scripted "intel."
In short, the people-in-space program is entirely evil. Let's be liberated by this revelation, folks -- not demoralized.
AMEN!
Lies = Bondage. Truth = Freedom = "Way, Truth, and Life."
Liberator posted on 2020-01-18 11:09:25 Reply Private Reply
#205: NeoconsNailed To: Liberator (#204)
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-01-18 11:17:39 Reply Private Reply
#206: Liberator To: NeoconsNailed (#205)
I gotcha and understood you perfectly; You spoke and conveyed thoughts in general terms, and in no way did you make it personal.
Truth IS truth. It may ruffle feathers and anger some people, but that is what it is.
Liberator posted on 2020-01-18 11:22:03 Reply Private Reply
#207: Liberator To: wudidiz (#202)
LOVE the Maximus meme!
Liberator posted on 2020-01-18 11:24:13 Reply Private Reply
#208: Liberator To: wudidiz, 4 (#201)
SPECTACULAR maxims.
They bear repeating...
They are important reminders of ALL of our natural thought processes at some point or another.
It reminds me of a position that may surprise many...
*I* researched my own past posts on the subject and lo and behold, had expressed my own theory not so long ago at LF to Deckard with respect to "Flat Earth." I had responded to it by theorizing that the "Flat Earth" movement was a "CT" designed by elements of the PTB to "discredit" ALL "CTs".
To my eventual utter shock....I was wrong.
The reasons I was wrong was because like most of us, I had been programmed and mind-imprinted, assuming "established facts" without trusting my own observations, common sense, real science, and several Scriptural descriptions of our realm made by its Creator.
Liberator posted on 2020-01-18 11:45:04 Reply Private Reply
#209: NeoconsNailed To: Liberator (#203)
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-01-18 13:02:54 Reply Private Reply
#210: FormerLurker To: NeoconsNailed (#190)
Dude. You can spot the ISS yourself using an app on your phone to tell you when and where it'll be in the sky in your area of the world.
I've seen it twice myself.
Once was on an early morning before the sun rose, I was checking the sky where it was supposed to appear, and lo and behold there was this bright object in the sky tracking exactly where it was supposed to. I used astronomical binoculars to get a good look and I could actually make out the shape of the solar panels.
Another time I was up in Canada visiting relatives, and I showed them how cool the app was. It was about to pass right over head practically and I got them to go outside to take a look.
Sure enough it appeared right where it was supposed to and traversed the sky according the projected path on the app.
Space travel isn't make believe dude. You know not too long ago some people didn't think men could fly either.
But in terms of the app, it can tell you where communication and weather satellites will be in sky as well. You need to get out of everything is a conspiracy mindset.
I think the big problem is that people today are afraid to accept the fact that the universe is a REALLY big place, and like to limit their worldview to something more acceptable to what they can deal with.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-18 17:31:38 Reply Private Reply
#211: FormerLurker To: wudidiz (#191)
Take a picture of a bacteria with your own camera and post it here. Oh wait, you can't.
Bacteria don't exist, nope. Checkmate, doctors have lied to you... LOL!!!
Here's another one. Go to an eastern US seacoast and take a picture of the Eiffel tower with your own camera. You can even use a telescope to help you see it.
Oh wait, you can't because the Eiffel tower is thousands of miles past the horizon.
You know how far the horizon is?
From How Far Away is the Horizon?
So if you're in the middle of the ocean and you're 6 feet tall, you can only see an area of about 9 square miles. That's why we need to use compasses and plot our position using navigation techniques such as using the position of the sun by day and the stars at night to traverse the ocean from point A to point B, using GLOBAL coordinates. And no, you can't see Europe from Cape Cod or anywhere else on the east coast of the US.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-18 17:41:58 Reply Private Reply
#212: FormerLurker To: Liberator (#208)
You're still in the ridicule and violently oppose stage of truth that has already been known and accepted for centuries.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-18 17:48:32 Reply Private Reply
#213: FormerLurker To: Liberator (#204)
I find it comical that you believe some unknown author of a book of dubious origin, yet ignore and disbelieve obvious facts that any reasonably sane person could easily understand and prove with simple observations.
Religion is a FAITH based belief system devoid of any provable facts.
Science is the logical and fact based system of DISCOVERY of universal laws and facts that can be proven using well known methods that produce repeatable results.
Again, explain to me if gravity doesn't exist, why then do objects fall to the ground if they are dropped. You have ignored the simple question at least 2 or 3 times already on this thread.
If you believe science is fake, then toss out your cell phone, have your electricity shut off, and go build yourself a cabin out in the wilderness without modern tools.
Because back in the days of Jesus, if he did actually exist, electricity hadn't yet been discovered never mind harnessed, and modern tools obviously didn't exist yet either.
Your view of the earth and the rest of creation is about that of cavemen. Even the authors of the Book of Genesis had more understanding, as the actual Hebrew speaks much differently about matters than the various translations.
For instance, where the King James bible would say, "God created man in his own image", it actually says "God created MANKIND in THEIR own image".
You've been duped.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-18 18:07:27 Reply Private Reply
#214: FormerLurker To: Liberator (#204)
That's why you should toss out your lies and try to educate yourself to actual truth.
And this is also why I can't really believe you're that stupid to actually believe the lies you spew, as on other threads you at least at one time appeared to be well versed on various other topics.
Maybe someone hacked your account and you're not even the real Liberator. But no, you were spouting the same nonsense on LF.
Did Stone kick you?
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-18 18:14:40 Reply Private Reply
#215: FormerLurker To: wudidiz (#192)
Did you know that people have well understood the earth to be a sphere for about 500 years, at least in terms of modern history?
Ancient civilizations also understood the earth wasn't flat and knew it had to be spherical because of the appearance of ships at sea. They could only see them coming in to a harbor when they were about 3 miles away.
They would observe the tops of the masts before they could see the rest of the ship.
Going out to sea they would observe the opposite affect, where the masts were the last thing to be seen of the ship.
You're ridiculous memes don't have any bit of common sense and appear to be created by someone who never opened a book beyond comic books.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-18 18:33:15 Reply Private Reply
#216: NeoconsNailed To: FormerLurker (#210)
Their images sometimes flicker where the ISS they're supposedly speaking from doesn't and that spells only one thing: f-r-a-u-d.
We've covered the ISS and I shot it down.
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-01-18 19:24:27 Reply Private Reply
#217: titorite To: NeoconsNailed (#216)
We know the ISS is up there because we can follow it's transits with our own commercially available telescopes , that said, any scrutiny applied to what they say is from the inside of the iss reveals many many issues.
So the question might become, "if it is really up there what in the fuck would be the point of faking footage from the inside"?
To which I would respond, why wouldn't they? Why would they reveal the inner workings of the issues to the world and public at large including enemy nations that we would rather not see utilizing our technology.
I mean look at Iran. One of our server drones crashed there and with in a year they reverse engineered our predator drones.
If the footage was legit and real rouge states all over would be all over that.
No better survalence platform on earth or rather from low earth orbit.
titorite posted on 2020-01-18 20:55:07 Reply Private Reply
#218: FormerLurker To: All, wudidiz, Liberator (#211)
Gee whiz, was I trying to fool you to see who if any would catch my mistake, or did I do it by accident...
I was thinking in terms of a square. But if you can see 3 miles 360 degrees, then it is not a square, it is a circle.
The area of a square is the length of the square times the width, so the area A is the length * width of that square;
So a 3 mile(length) * 3 mile(width) square is 9 square miles in area(A).
A circle however has a different formula for area. We use the radius, 3 miles, to calculate the area as follows;
Area (A) = Pi * Radius Squared (r2)
So given a 3 mile radius, Area = 3.14 * (3 miles * 3 miles) = 28.6 square miles
So if you were in the middle of the ocean, being 6 foot tall, you'd be able to see a total of 28.6 square miles.
Gee whiz, why is that I wonder. Ever wonder why they'd position lookouts on ships into Crow's nest?
Isn't math cool?
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-18 22:21:12 Reply Private Reply
#219: FormerLurker To: NeoconsNailed (#216)
What the hell are you talking about dude?
Perhaps they meant the PUBLIC?
I skip really whacked out videos, but if you have definitive proof of what you claim, repost it if I missed something..
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-18 22:29:40 Reply Private Reply
#220: NeoconsNailed To: FormerLurker (#219)
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-01-18 23:53:21 Reply Private Reply
#221: NeoconsNailed To: titorite (#217)
All we know, my friend, is that something is up there. Ample evidence -- I'd say proof -- exists that it's not what's claimed.
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-01-19 00:07:54 Reply Private Reply
#222: FormerLurker To: NeoconsNailed (#220)
Bro I'm not going to fish through 200 posts and view an unknown number of videos to try to find something close to what you're talking about.
If you have proof of what you claim, you should be able to easily repost it.
One question though. Why do you think men couldn't orbit the earth in a space capsule, shuttle, or space station?
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-19 11:46:05 Reply Private Reply
#223: NeoconsNailed To: FormerLurker (#222)
Because NASA says so.
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-01-19 15:13:36 Reply Private Reply
#224: FormerLurker To: NeoconsNailed (#223)
So far I've only seen YOU saying that. Post credible references if any exist.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-19 18:20:22 Reply Private Reply
#225: FormerLurker To: NeoconsNailed (#223)
Without using that nonsensical argument, why do you think men can't orbit the earth?
We can travel in planes, some of which approach the edge of space in terms of military aircraft.
A space vessel is just a tightly pressured plane without wings. It's not magic bro.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-19 18:29:54 Reply Private Reply
#226: NeoconsNailed To: FormerLurker (#224)
Search it here yourself if you're that interested (you're not).
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-01-19 19:29:52 Reply Private Reply
#227: NeoconsNailed To: FormerLurker (#225)
NeoconsNailed posted on 2020-01-19 19:38:33 Reply Private Reply
#228: FormerLurker To: NeoconsNailed (#226)
So in other words you don't know of any evidence, or are not interested in debating the issue, you just want people to believe you without any evidence whatsoever.
Sorry bro, I don't believe you.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-20 17:55:35 Reply Private Reply
#229: FormerLurker To: NeoconsNailed (#227)
More like non-existent argument.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-20 17:56:05 Reply Private Reply
#230: Dakmar To: FormerLurker (#229)
Dakmar posted on 2020-01-20 19:54:07 Reply Private Reply
#231: Liberator To: Dakmar (#230)
The Elite often co-opt BOTH sides. I'm sure you're aware of their ploys.
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 12:21:32 Reply Private Reply
#232: Liberator To: NeoconsNailed (#227)
This analogy works because it applies:
I don't know many Third Graders who can understand learned subject matter from a senior in HS. Even if explained carefully to a Third Grader, the extra nine years of accumulated information from the HS Seniors will rarely "make sense" for obvious reasons. Ergo the Third Grader will dismiss it as "stupid."
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 12:34:58 Reply Private Reply
#233: Liberator To: NeoconsNailed, wudidiz, titorite, AllTheKings'HorsesWontDoIt, noone (#226)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yjw_DuNkOUw
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 12:38:48 Reply Private Reply
#234: Liberator To: NeoconsNailed, wudidiz, titorite, AllTheKings'HorsesWontDoIt, noone, Dakmar, All (#233)
NASA, their org, their "Missions," their "science," the entire Disney-like Theater:
ABSOLUTELY CRUSHED and ANNIHILATED.
What say you?
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 12:48:50 Reply Private Reply
#235: AllTheKings'HorsesWontDoIt To: Liberator (#234)
does it have anything to do with "NASA's spiritual roots" and a "fixed earth"?
AllTheKings'HorsesWontDoIt posted on 2020-01-21 14:55:33 Reply Private Reply
#236: Liberator To: AllTheKings'HorsesWontDoIt, NeoconNailed, wudiziz (#235)
I apologize, Kings; I shouldn't assume. I hope you can assess this or any of these amazing videos.
TITLE:
'Disney Presents: NASA on Thin Ice | Buzz Aldrin and the Masonic Moon'
(but it's much more than about that.)
does it have anything to do with "NASA's spiritual roots" and a "fixed earth"?
YES.
Some necessary history is reviewed. Some Science is reviewed. And many claims and observations are reviewed AND exposed.
NASA's roots are Nazi, Disney, Space Program, and Cultist "Magic"/Wizardry.
https://youtu.be/ZR296RWS0yM
AUTHOR'S OVERVIEW:
Disney Presents: NASA on Thin Ice | Buzz Aldrin and the Masonic Moon.
Disney brings the magic to life with Jack Parsons, L Ron Hubbard, Wernher Von Braun, Stanley Kubrick, Buzz Aldrin and the Apollo Program.
In this video we go over the recent history of the NASA deception with a easy to follow timeline from NACA transforming into NASA to Walt Disney creating some of the very first propaganda about impossible space travel with the film 'Man in Space.
Stanley Kubrick leaving us clues about filming the moon landing in room 237. They say the moon is 237,000 miles away which is why the room is called that.
NASA admits on several occasions that they can't go beyond low earth orbit due to the deadly Van Allen Radiation Belt, but that's only code for the firmament / dome.
We live on a level and stationary plane and we've been lied to about many things, including evolution, the moon landing, space travel, Antarctica, the shape of the earth, etc. Hollywood is constantly bomarding the minds of the masses with the idea that outer space exists in the capacity we are told by mainstream science which has been proven wrong time and time again.
OTHER WELL-RESEARCHED VIDEOS BY THIS AUTHOR:
The Case for Flat Earth | ODD TV Presentation:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8udts...
NASA Fails Again & Again | Space is Fake | Glitch on the ISS:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nS0VN...
History of Fake Space | Outer Space Does Not Exist:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ss7QT...
Flat Earth Timeline | The History of Flat Earth:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IIB2U...
A Stranger's Guide to Flat Earth | 21 Questions and Answers (Proving The Earth Is Flat):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0xCl...
Journey to the Center of the Flat Earth | North Pole Hidden Land:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRhZI...
Flat Earth | As Seen on TV | Movies & Television Shows:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9jnse...
Bill Nye Indoctrinates the World | Why Flat Earth Matters:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_jyLG...
Flat Earth | Amber Plaster | Earth Not A Globe | Moana - How Far I'll Go Song:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJ5HJ...
Flat Earth & Project Blue Beam:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aFFM3...
Flat Earth | Seven Planets of the Universe | The Wandering Stars:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IQQOh...
Flat Earth & the Fisheye Lens:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXkCg...
NASA Can't Go Beyond Low Earth Orbit | Flat Earth Firmament:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fmoiw...
Flat Earth | 100% Proof Space Travel is Fake & Mars Missions are Too:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S9i97...
ODD TV's Flat Earth Trilogy | True World, Learning Curve and Epic Deception:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ARp2j...
Neil deGrasse Tyson Exposed | Hollywood Actor:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KcqFD...
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 17:30:11 Reply Private Reply
#237: Liberator To: wudidiz (#236)
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 17:31:40 Reply Private Reply
#238: FormerLurker To: Liberator, NeoconsNailed (#232)
Apparently you didn't read what was being discussed. The simple question was about posting a link to the proof of an assertion that was claimed to be the basis for the assertion.
Here's a question for you.
Why do objects fall to the ground if dropped?
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-21 17:40:29 Reply Private Reply
#239: FormerLurker To: Liberator (#236)
Go find a telescope and observe the stars and planets. You'll see that is the case.
Also, find one with a motorized mount so that the earth's rotation doesn't make you lose track of the planet you're watching, as it'll move across the lens in seconds if you're trying to do it manually.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-21 17:43:12 Reply Private Reply
#240: Liberator To: FormerLurker (#238)
Simple case of Mass & Density.
(There is almost an hour of video that refutes it. You likely won't watch even 5 minutes of it, BUT, you just might learn something.)
There is NO such thing as "Gravity." Yes, yes -- I know you're going to cite Newton. But Newton even admitted his "discovery" was just a THEORY.
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 17:54:20 Reply Private Reply
#241: FormerLurker To: Liberator (#234)
I stopped watching it there.
However, the link between JPL,Crowley, and Hubbard was a very curious thing. I've known about it, but it doesn't change the fact the earth is not flat.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-21 17:54:30 Reply Private Reply
#242: FormerLurker To: Liberator (#240)
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-21 17:55:01 Reply Private Reply
#243: FormerLurker To: Liberator (#240)
No. You need a force to move an object.
Force is Mass * Acceleration
When you push a box across the floor you have to exert a force upon that box for it to move.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-21 17:59:54 Reply Private Reply
#244: FormerLurker To: All (#243)
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-21 18:11:22 Reply Private Reply
#245: Liberator To: FormerLurker (#239)
People have merely theorized the Heliocentric model as dogma. Just as "Gravity" is a dogmatic "theory"; as are the alleged formulas for astronomical "distance," and "size" of alleged stars.
It is also assumed that celestial bodies are indeed globes and NOT discs. Man can NOT see these objects in 3-D.
Moreover, "stars" are not what we've been led to believe. The true shape of these objects is far from what we've been led to believe.
For the vast majority of history, people have KNOWN our realm is still and un-moving. Ours is a geocentric realm. a great PLAIN.
The stars? THEY move over EARTH as we remain stationary. If this wasn't the case, according to the heliocentric theory, the stars in the sky SHOULD be totally different were our alleged globe on the OTHER SIDE of the sun. (Can you explain why they remain positioned in EXACTLY THE SAME PLACE, regardless?) Moreover...because the stars remain positioned perfectly, predictably, and the SAME year in and year out, they've been used as THE perfect sky "map" from which to guide travelers or navigate the sea throughout the millennia.
Go find a telescope and observe the stars and planets. You'll see that is the case.
Others have done so. Repeatedly. THAT is "Science." The ABOVE is indeed proven.
And yes --the ONLY celestial bodies which move opposite of the usual star paths ARE planets,, described as "wondering stars" in Scripture.
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 18:13:13 Reply Private Reply
#246: Liberator To: FormerLurker (#243)
(did you bother watching ANY of that vid?)
What does "force" have to do with the necessity to "move an object"? What is the goal?
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 18:14:51 Reply Private Reply
#247: Liberator To: FormerLurker (#243)
Ok. That's acceptable science. But what's he point?
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 18:15:47 Reply Private Reply
#248: FormerLurker To: All (#244)
Force of Gravity (g) = Mass (m) * Acceleration due to gravity (32 ft per second squared)
This is true of earth gravity at sea level.
At higher altitudes you would use the following equation to determine the force;
F = G((m1* m2)/r2).
Where F is force, G is the gravitational constant, m1 is the mass of object 1, and m2 is the mass of object 2. r is the distance between their centers of mass. In the formula it is squared.
Is is how we put objects into space and keep them in orbit.
It's also what makes plotting the trajectory of ballistic missiles difficult, as the force of gravity changes the higher the missile goes.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-21 18:25:17 Reply Private Reply
#249: Liberator To: FormerLurker (#241)
At 4:23, what point is being made, and what context?
I need more than that.
(did you dismiss or discredit all of what was claimed up till that point?)
the link between JPL,Crowley, and Hubbard was a very curious thing. I've known about it, but it doesn't change the fact the earth is not flat.
I appreciate that you did focus on the info...and what you'd watched even to that point. I absolutely realize all of this "opposite" or new stuff related to our realm, the cosmos, theories on creation and time are challenging. (and some of it "impossible.")
No one point is designed to change your mind on anything; That's all up to you. It is the eventual weight of accumulative new info and data that helped *me* understand and/or unravel/re-consider all new theories. (That the govt, MSM, academe, and PTB have been lying to us about everything is what finally led me to re-consider what I'd been told is "100% true.")
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 18:26:43 Reply Private Reply
#250: FormerLurker To: Liberator (#249)
I told you where to look. It asserts that the Gemini video of the space walk is fake.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-21 18:28:58 Reply Private Reply
#251: Liberator To: FormerLurker (#248)
"Formulas" on a chalkboard still aren't definitive "proof" of the existence of "Gravity."
There's air pressure to consider -- as well as mass and density in relation to the mass and density of surrounding media.
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 18:29:28 Reply Private Reply
#252: Liberator To: FormerLurker (#250)
It IS.
But for the sake of argument, do you believe the "space walk" event is occurring in low earth orbit?
Liberator posted on 2020-01-21 18:31:11 Reply Private Reply
#253: FormerLurker To: Liberator (#249)
Don't confuse the fantasy realm with the objective world we live in.
There are some that have dabbled into things that they shouldn't have.
Perhaps for that reason we have some extremely evil people running things.
But the earth is still a sphere, and the sun is but one star out of an unimaginable number.
FormerLurker posted on 2020-01-21 18:32:06 Reply Private Reply